Re: MIT and Expat licenses; licenses 'similar to' a BSD license (Re: [DEP-5] [patch] License table: more links and licenses.)

2010-08-15 Thread MJ Ray
Carsten Hey wrote: > * Charles Plessy [2010-08-15 00:20 +0900]: > > Le Sat, Aug 14, 2010 at 01:26:45PM +0200, Carsten Hey a écrit : > > > Shouldn't it be mentioned in the licenses description that the expat > > > license sometimes wrongly is referred to as MIT license? > > > > I wonder if the tradi

Re: [DEP-5] [patch] License table: more links and licenses.

2010-08-15 Thread Charles Plessy
Le Sun, Aug 15, 2010 at 07:16:49AM +1200, Lars Wirzenius a écrit : > > I would, however, keep a short list of shortnames for the versioned > licenses in /usr/share/common-licenses (excluding BSD, plain GFDL, plain > GPL, plain LGPL, plain Artistic): Apache-2.0, GFDL-1.2, GFDL-1.3, GPL-1, > GPL-2,

Re: [DEP-5] [patch] License table: more links and licenses.

2010-08-14 Thread Craig Small
On Sun, Aug 15, 2010 at 07:16:49AM +1200, Lars Wirzenius wrote: > perhaps too much effort. Since the list really should be shared with > other projects (SPDX and Fedora especially), it would perhaps make most > sense to refer to it instead of incorporating it in the spec. > > I would, however, kee

Re: [SPAM:####] Re: [DEP-5] [patch] License table: more links and licenses.

2010-08-14 Thread Russ Allbery
Lars Wirzenius writes: > Actually, I am starting to think that maintaining a long list of license > shortnames in DEP-5, many of which refer to rarely used licenses, is > perhaps too much effort. Since the list really should be shared with > other projects (SPDX and Fedora especially), it would p

Re: [DEP-5] [patch] License table: more links and licenses.

2010-08-14 Thread Lars Wirzenius
On la, 2010-08-14 at 16:58 +0900, Charles Plessy wrote: > After looking at http://spdx.org/licenses/, I realise that the very > existence of a license list in DEP-5 is in question (not in this thread). > However, since I had a version of the DEP with a more comprehensive use > of web links for lice

Re: MIT and Expat licenses; lice nses ‘similar to’ a BSD licens e (Re: [DEP-5] [patch] License table: more links and licenses.)

2010-08-14 Thread Jonas Smedegaard
On Sat, Aug 14, 2010 at 06:39:26PM +0200, Carsten Hey wrote: * Charles Plessy [2010-08-15 00:20 +0900]: If consensus converges on using a ‘similar to’ keyword, I will submit a patch. I see the problem you want so solve and I'm unsure if a such a keyword addition would finally make DEP-5 eas

Re: MIT and Expat licenses; lice nses ‘similar to’ a BSD licens e (Re: [DEP-5] [patch] License table: more links and licenses.)

2010-08-14 Thread Carsten Hey
* Charles Plessy [2010-08-15 00:20 +0900]: > Le Sat, Aug 14, 2010 at 01:26:45PM +0200, Carsten Hey a écrit : > > > > Shouldn't it be mentioned in the licenses description that the expat > > license sometimes wrongly is referred to as MIT license? > > I wonder if the tradition of using the “Expat” n

MIT and Expat licenses; licenses ‘similar to’ a BSD licens e (Re: [DEP-5] [patch] License table: more links and licenses.)

2010-08-14 Thread Charles Plessy
Le Sat, Aug 14, 2010 at 01:26:45PM +0200, Carsten Hey a écrit : > > Shouldn't it be mentioned in the licenses description that the expat > license sometimes wrongly is referred to as MIT license? Hi Carsten, I wonder if the tradition of using the “Expat” name to refer unambiguously to one of the

Re: [DEP-5] [patch] License table: more links and licenses.

2010-08-14 Thread Carsten Hey
* Charles Plessy [2010-08-14 16:58 +0900]: > After looking at http://spdx.org/licenses/, I realise that the very > existence of a license list in DEP-5 is in question (not in this thread). > However, since I had a version of the DEP with a more comprehensive use > of web links for licenses, I propo

[DEP-5] [patch] License table: more links and licenses.

2010-08-14 Thread Charles Plessy
After looking at http://spdx.org/licenses/, I realise that the very existence of a license list in DEP-5 is in question (not in this thread). However, since I had a version of the DEP with a more comprehensive use of web links for licenses, I propose the attached patch anyway. I also propose the a