Bug#616465: debian-policy: description file in each system directory

2011-04-05 Thread Russ Allbery
sergey writes: > I do not know Debian internal structure well. Is it possible that Debian > has other place for my suggestion? Some document that give global > recommendations for cases other than system components interoperability? Kind of, in the Developer's Reference. There isn't a lot of th

Bug#616465: debian-policy: description file in each system directory

2011-04-05 Thread sergey
On Sun, 03 Apr 2011 20:17:03 -0700 Russ Allbery wrote: > Hi sergey, > > For the reasons already discussed by others, I don't think that Policy is > the appropriate place to do this. There's definitely some merit to the > idea, but I don't think it rises to the level of making it a Policy > reco

Bug#616465: debian-policy: description file in each system directory

2011-04-03 Thread Russ Allbery
sergey writes: > What do you think about placing README in each system directory? > IMHO it make system exploration more interesting for new users and can > be helpful for expirienced users too. > Now Debian 6 already contain READMEs in some system directories: > /etc/init.d/README, > /etc/grub

Bug#616465: debian-policy: description file in each system directory

2011-03-06 Thread sergey
Hi Jonathan, Jonathan wrote: > It's true that there is no obvious place for feature suggestions with > no individual taking responsibility (I am hesitant to suggest the > "general" pseudopackage). Did you mean category with number 11 from reportbug's list? $ reportbug Please enter the name of

Bug#616465: debian-policy: description file in each system directory

2011-03-05 Thread Jonathan Nieder
(-cc: Steve since he is already subscribed to -policy) Hi Sergey, sergey wrote: > I agree that it is a good place for proposals like mine. > But making long well-developed draft and "driving" it - this is > mostly operating system developer's task, not users one. > I think that Debian should have

Bug#616465: debian-policy: description file in each system directory

2011-03-05 Thread sergey
Hi Jonathan, > Policy sets rules that make sure the system works well. > ... > Perhaps the following might provide some inspiration: > > http://dep.debian.net/deps/dep0/ I agree that it is a good place for proposals like mine. But making long well-developed draft and "driving" it - this i

Bug#616465: debian-policy: description file in each system directory

2011-03-05 Thread Jonathan Nieder
Hi Sergey, sergey wrote: > Does Debian policy can recommend something (including READMEs)? Or policy can > only > force something, no recommendations is possible? Policy sets rules that make sure the system works well. These can be hard requirements (generally using the word "must"), which cor

Bug#616465: debian-policy: description file in each system directory

2011-03-05 Thread sergey
On Fri, 4 Mar 2011 15:33:00 -0600 Jonathan Nieder wrote: > To throw an idea out, I wonder if making the filesystem hierarchy > standard (http://www.pathname.com/fhs/) more visible could have the > same effect? For example, there could be a package providing > READMEs in system directories contai

Bug#616465: debian-policy: description file in each system directory

2011-03-04 Thread Jonathan Nieder
Hi Sergey! sergey wrote: > What do you think about placing README in each system directory? I think the idea is interesting but agree with Steve that policy is not the best way to move it forward. Packages already can put README files in particularly mysterious directories, and I don't see a co

Bug#616465: debian-policy: description file in each system directory

2011-03-04 Thread Steve Langasek
On Fri, Mar 04, 2011 at 08:37:45PM +0300, sergey wrote: > What do you think about placing README in each system directory? I think it's fine if maintainers of relevant packages want to do this, but it's not anything that Policy should be enforcing. > /etc/init.d/README, I think I was running Deb

Bug#616465: debian-policy: description file in each system directory

2011-03-04 Thread sergey
Package: debian-policy Severity: wishlist Excuse me for my bad English :-) What do you think about placing README in each system directory? IMHO it make system exploration more interesting for new users and can be helpful for expirienced users too. Now Debian 6 already contain READMEs in som