Bug#694883: copyright-format: author != copyright, add an author field?

2014-02-03 Thread Jonathan Nieder
Just forwarding to bug#694883 ("please clarify the recommended form for public domain files") for easy reference. Thanks, Jonathan --- Begin Message --- On 03/02/14 20:55, Jonathan Nieder wrote: > Daniel Pocock wrote: > >> I've only come across one package which included public-domain material

Bug#737559: copyright-format: author != copyright, add an author field?

2014-02-03 Thread Daniel Pocock
On 03/02/14 21:58, Russ Allbery wrote: > Daniel Pocock writes: > >> There are cases where I would have used it and I believe that >> recognising people's work (even if they have assigned their rights) is >> an important way of showing our thanks and acknowledgment to those who >> develop free s

Bug#737559: copyright-format: author != copyright, add an author field?

2014-02-03 Thread Russ Allbery
Daniel Pocock writes: > There are cases where I would have used it and I believe that > recognising people's work (even if they have assigned their rights) is > an important way of showing our thanks and acknowledgment to those who > develop free software, and having a dedicated field makes them

Bug#737559: copyright-format: author != copyright, add an author field?

2014-02-03 Thread Daniel Pocock
On 03/02/14 20:55, Jonathan Nieder wrote: > Daniel Pocock wrote: > >> I've only come across one package which included public-domain material >> so far. In this case, I put a note about the author in the comments. > > Yep - that works, too. > > [...] >> One risk of not having this extra field

Bug#737559: copyright-format: author != copyright, add an author field?

2014-02-03 Thread Jonathan Nieder
Daniel Pocock wrote: > I've only come across one package which included public-domain material > so far. In this case, I put a note about the author in the comments. Yep - that works, too. [...] > One risk of not having this extra field is that we could accumulate > excessive things in the Copy

Processed: Re: copyright-format: author != copyright, add an author field?

2014-02-03 Thread Debian Bug Tracking System
Processing commands for cont...@bugs.debian.org: > severity 678607 important Bug #678607 [debian-policy] "original authors" in 12.5 is unclear Severity set to 'important' from 'normal' > End of message, stopping processing here. Please contact me if you need assistance. -- 678607: http://bugs.de

Bug#737559: copyright-format: author != copyright, add an author field?

2014-02-03 Thread Daniel Pocock
On 03/02/14 20:36, Jonathan Nieder wrote: > Daniel Pocock wrote: > >> Just to clarify, I do not believe that maintaining this field should be >> obligatory >> >> It should be an optional field >> >> Defining it formally in the standard and having some examples will help >> emphasize the differen

Bug#737559: copyright-format: author != copyright, add an author field?

2014-02-03 Thread Jonathan Nieder
Daniel Pocock wrote: > Just to clarify, I do not believe that maintaining this field should be > obligatory > > It should be an optional field > > Defining it formally in the standard and having some examples will help > emphasize the difference between what people should put in the Copyright > fi

Bug#737559: copyright-format: author != copyright, add an author field?

2014-02-03 Thread Steve Langasek
On Mon, Feb 03, 2014 at 08:22:25PM +0100, Daniel Pocock wrote: > Just to clarify, I do not believe that maintaining this field should be > obligatory > It should be an optional field > Defining it formally in the standard and having some examples will help > emphasize the difference between what

Bug#737559: copyright-format: author != copyright, add an author field?

2014-02-03 Thread Daniel Pocock
On 03/02/14 20:17, Jonathan Nieder wrote: > severity 737559 wishlist > user debian-pol...@packages.debian.org > usertags 737559 = normative issue > quit > > Hi Daniel, > > Daniel Pocock wrote: > >> Author and copyright holder are not always the same person/entity. > [...] >> License: GPL2 >> C

Bug#737559: copyright-format: author != copyright, add an author field?

2014-02-03 Thread Jonathan Nieder
severity 737559 wishlist user debian-pol...@packages.debian.org usertags 737559 = normative issue quit Hi Daniel, Daniel Pocock wrote: > Author and copyright holder are not always the same person/entity. [...] > License: GPL2 > Copyright: 2014, Acme, Inc http://acme.example.org > Author: Bob, ht

Processed: Re: copyright-format: author != copyright, add an author field?

2014-02-03 Thread Debian Bug Tracking System
Processing commands for cont...@bugs.debian.org: > severity 737559 wishlist Bug #737559 [debian-policy] copyright-format: author != copyright, add an author field? Severity set to 'wishlist' from 'normal' > user debian-pol...@packages.debian.org Setting user to debian-pol...@packages.debian.org (

Bug#737559: copyright-format: author != copyright, add an author field?

2014-02-03 Thread Daniel Pocock
Package: debian-policy Author and copyright holder are not always the same person/entity. E.g. the work may be authored by Bob but the copyright is assigned to his employer Acme, Inc, e.g. License: GPL2 Copyright: 2014, Acme, Inc http://acme.example.org Author: Bob, http://example.org/bob For c