Re: unexpected changes - live-bottom/13swap running by default

2008-09-02 Thread Michal Suchanek
On 31/08/2008, Daniel Baumann <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Chris Lamb wrote: > > The "we do not touch filesystems by default" invariant is really important. > > > > As long as one can pass "swap" at boot time to revert the behaviour, I > would > > be in favour of the above change. > > > after

Re: unexpected changes - live-bottom/13swap running by default

2008-09-02 Thread intrigeri
Hello, here’s my answer, read bellow for arguments: [ ] Use swap partitions automatically in all flavours (leave as is) [x] Don't use swap partitions automatically in all flavours [ ] Use swap partitions for standard and desktop flavours, use noswap for rescue flavour. Joseph Rawson wrote (3

Re: unexpected changes - live-bottom/13swap running by default

2008-08-31 Thread Marco Amadori
Il domenica 31 agosto 2008 23:53:28 Tzafrir Cohen ha scritto: > > > The "we do not touch filesystems by default" invariant is really > > > important. It is not really a filesystem, but I got it. > > > As long as one can pass "swap" at boot time to revert the behaviour, I > > > would > > > be in

Re: unexpected changes - live-bottom/13swap running by default

2008-08-31 Thread Tzafrir Cohen
On Sun, Aug 31, 2008 at 03:04:09PM -0400, Harold wrote: > > Daniel Baumann wrote: > > > >> [ ] Use swap partitions automatically in all flavours (leave as is) > >> [X] Don't use swap partitions automatically in all flavours > >> [ ] Use swap partitions for standard and desktop flavours, > >> us

Re: unexpected changes - live-bottom/13swap running by default

2008-08-31 Thread Daniel Baumann
Joseph Rawson wrote: > The one that makes a short description of what each lh_(something) script > does > and the stage files it requires and creates. I've not been in a position to > be able to do this in a long time, but that seems to be changing. This is > also something that should proba

Re: unexpected changes - live-bottom/13swap running by default

2008-08-31 Thread Joseph Rawson
On Sunday 31 August 2008 05:56:57 Daniel Baumann wrote: > Hi, > Hi. :) > Thank you, any help with improving the documentation is very welcome. > np I still would like to finish the wiki page that I started long ago. The one that makes a short description of what each lh_(something) script does

Re: unexpected changes - live-bottom/13swap running by default

2008-08-31 Thread Harold
> Daniel Baumann wrote: > >> [ ] Use swap partitions automatically in all flavours (leave as is) >> [X] Don't use swap partitions automatically in all flavours >> [ ] Use swap partitions for standard and desktop flavours, >> use noswap for rescue flavour. > > The "we do not touch filesystems by

Re: unexpected changes - live-bottom/13swap running by default

2008-08-31 Thread Chris Lamb
Daniel Baumann wrote: > will adjust live-initramfs then, the default behaviour should not > require parameters, so.. instead of noswap you'll have to set autoswap > or something simillar in order to make use of the automatic swap usage > feature. For completeness, this was committed as 'swapon'.

Re: unexpected changes - live-bottom/13swap running by default

2008-08-31 Thread Daniel Baumann
Chris Lamb wrote: > The "we do not touch filesystems by default" invariant is really important. > > As long as one can pass "swap" at boot time to revert the behaviour, I would > be in favour of the above change. after thinking this afternoon about it, i agree. will adjust live-initramfs then, t

Re: unexpected changes - live-bottom/13swap running by default

2008-08-31 Thread Chris Lamb
Daniel Baumann wrote: > [ ] Use swap partitions automatically in all flavours (leave as is) > [X] Don't use swap partitions automatically in all flavours > [ ] Use swap partitions for standard and desktop flavours, > use noswap for rescue flavour. The "we do not touch filesystems by default"

Re: unexpected changes - live-bottom/13swap running by default

2008-08-31 Thread tomas
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 On Sun, Aug 31, 2008 at 12:56:57PM +0200, Daniel Baumann wrote: [...] > flavours sucks too, let's do a poll: > > [ ] Use swap partitions automatically in all flavours (leave as is) > [X] Don't use swap partitions automatically in all flavours > [ ]

Re: unexpected changes - live-bottom/13swap running by default

2008-08-31 Thread Daniel Baumann
Marco Amadori wrote: > How? Could you elaborate? "Since having different settings for the desktop flavours and the rescue flavours sucks too [...]" ...different official images should only differ in package selection, not in their behaviour. Regards, Daniel -- Address:Daniel Baumann, B

Re: unexpected changes - live-bottom/13swap running by default

2008-08-31 Thread Marco Amadori
Il domenica 31 agosto 2008 14:24:20 Daniel Baumann ha scritto: > Ronny Standtke wrote: > >> [x] Use swap partitions for standard and desktop flavours, > >> use noswap for rescue flavour. > > ...which would be the worst decision from a debian point of view. How? Could you elaborate? -- ESC:wq

Re: unexpected changes - live-bottom/13swap running by default

2008-08-31 Thread Daniel Baumann
Ronny Standtke wrote: >> [x] Use swap partitions for standard and desktop flavours, >> use noswap for rescue flavour. ...which would be the worst decision from a debian point of view. -- Address:Daniel Baumann, Burgunderstrasse 3, CH-4562 Biberist Email: [EMAIL PROTECTED] In

Re: unexpected changes - live-bottom/13swap running by default

2008-08-31 Thread Ronny Standtke
> Since having different settings for the desktop flavours and the rescue > flavours sucks too, let's do a poll: > > [ ] Use swap partitions automatically in all flavours (leave as is) > [ ] Don't use swap partitions automatically in all flavours > [x] Use swap partitions for standard and desktop f

Re: unexpected changes - live-bottom/13swap running by default

2008-08-31 Thread Daniel Baumann
Hi, Joseph Rawson wrote: > The document I'm working on > is located here. http://paella.berlios.de/quickstart-vbox.html This > document might make a good example of how to test the "net" images with > virtualization, and may be hacked to fit on the > http://wiki.debian.org/DebianLive/Virtual

unexpected changes - live-bottom/13swap running by default

2008-08-31 Thread Joseph Rawson
For the last 2-3 weeks, I've been working on a step-by-step document to get paella up and running for people. I have decided to use live-helper to make the nfsroot installer, since my self-made live nfs installer was really hacky, and there was not any decent alternative. The document I'm work