Debian-approved creative/content license?

2007-03-10 Thread Michael Gilbert
Hello, On the latest Linux Action Show [1], there was discussion about freeing their title track and content of their show. I was going to respond and suggest the right way to do this, but quickly found that there is no clear answer (especially when it comes to Debian). I've read up and found t

RFP: stix-fonts -- the Scientific and Technical Information eXchange fonts

2007-11-03 Thread Michael Gilbert
Package: wnpp Severity: wishlist * Package name: stix-fonts Version : beta-20071031 Upstream Author : STI Pub Companies <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> * URL : http://www.stixfonts.org * License : STIX Fonts User License (similar to other open fonts) Programming Lang: non

Policy on Binary Firmware Fetching in Main (e.g. foo2zjs)

2007-11-09 Thread Michael Gilbert
i recently submitted a serious bug against foo2zjs because the package provides a non-free firmware fetching script (called getweb) in main. i believe this to be a serious bug for two reasons: the first is that packages in main should not have any dependencies on non-free software. however, debia

Re: Policy on Binary Firmware Fetching in Main (e.g. foo2zjs)

2007-11-11 Thread Michael Gilbert
Marco d'Itri wrote: No, it's a very different case since here we have a large free self-contained free software program which works without any non-free dependencies, whose package also contains an additional little script which downloads and copies to an external device some file. There is clea

Re: Policy on Binary Firmware Fetching in Main (e.g. foo2zjs)

2007-11-11 Thread Michael Gilbert
i received the following message from the upstream author of foo2zjs. it is his belief that much of the package should be non-free. see below. Rick Richardson wrote: > It is not the firmware only. It is also ICC/ICM Color Correction files. > And PATENTS. Patents by IBM and ATT in the USA and

Re: Re: Policy on Binary Firmware Fetching in Main (e.g. foo2zjs)

2007-11-12 Thread Michael Gilbert
You are missing the point: some printers may or may not work, but the program itself still has the same capabilities and is not influenced by what getweb does. that's why it is ok for most of the program to be in main. its just getweb that depends on non-free data. this could easily be remedi

Re: Re: Policy on Binary Firmware Fetching in Main (e.g. foo2zjs)

2007-11-12 Thread Michael Gilbert
and since getweb depends on non-free software and is a part of the package, foo2zjs as a whole is considered to depend on non-free software. No. getweb *downloads* and copies some non-free software, it does not depend on it. does getweb function correctly if the external files are unable to b

Re: Policy on Binary Firmware Fetching in Main (e.g. foo2zjs)

2007-11-14 Thread Michael Gilbert
To use a rough analogy, compiz doesn't work on certain graphics cards unless one uses the proprietary driver for that card, but that doesn't in itself make compiz non-free. right, but this situation is different. so lets assume that foo2zjs is analogous to compiz and the printer firmware is a

Re: Policy on Binary Firmware Fetching in Main (e.g. foo2zjs)

2007-11-14 Thread Michael Gilbert
Stephen Gran wrote: does getweb function correctly if the external files are unable to be downloaded? That's not a very useful question - does a web browser function 'correctly' when it gets a 404? It depends entirely on what you mean by correctly, and that starts to feel like there's no bri

Re: Policy on Binary Firmware Fetching in Main (e.g. foo2zjs)

2007-11-14 Thread Michael Gilbert
You are missing the point: some printers may or may not work, but the program itself still has the same capabilities and is not influenced by what getweb does. that's why it is ok for most of the program to be in main. its just getweb that depends on non-free data. No, it does not. you missed

Freeness of code automatically generated from RFCs?

2015-01-24 Thread Michael Gilbert
Hi, I came across a curiosity while updating the wine package today. I noticed that upstream wine generates one of their source files from the contents of RFC3454 [0]. There is a tool (tools/make_unicode) that among other things downloads the RFC from rfc-editor.org and generates nameprep.c. Th

Re: Freeness of code automatically generated from RFCs?

2015-01-24 Thread Michael Gilbert
On Sat, Jan 24, 2015 at 11:36 PM, Michael Gilbert wrote: > Hi, > > I came across a curiosity while updating the wine package today. I > noticed that upstream wine generates one of their source files from > the contents of RFC3454 [0]. > > There is a tool (tools/make_unic