Re: migrating away from the FDL

2003-07-20 Thread J.D. Hood
--- Mathieu Roy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > But the freedom the project cares about are almost the same. [...] > This whole GNU FDL issue indeed show (minor) differences between > Debian and GNU but I'm not sure this issue allows us to say "This one > is better than this other one in terms of fr

Re: migrating away from the FDL

2003-07-20 Thread J.D. Hood
--- Andrew Suffield <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > On Sun, Jul 20, 2003 at 09:18:32AM +0100, J.D. Hood wrote: > > That is not surprising, given that Debian, unlike the FSF, is not a > > monarchy. > > ITYM "autocracy". > > A monarchy is an autoc

Re: migrating away from the FDL

2003-07-20 Thread J.D. Hood
--- Dylan Thurston <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > [...] please > note that Richard Stallman does _not_ advocate different standards of > freedom for documentation and for software, according to, for instance, > http://lists.debian.org/debian-legal/2003/debian-legal-200305/msg00593.html Any two thi

Re: migrating away from the FDL

2003-07-19 Thread J.D. Hood
--- Florian Weimer <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > To my knowledge, only a very vocal minority of Debian Developers > argues for the removal of documentation licensed under the GFDL (and > even their views are far from consistent). No one has surveyed DDs on this question, have they? > You guys mig

Defining 'preferred form for making modifications'

2003-06-15 Thread J.D. Hood
I suggest that the definition of 'preferred form for making modifications' be information-theoretical. When source code is compiled into binary code there is a loss of information, as indicated by the fact that you cannot get the original source back, given only the binary code. On the other hand

Re: A single unified license

2003-06-15 Thread J.D. Hood
The idea of writing a single license for both software and documentation (i.e., for "content") is a good one. Perhaps this could be done in GPL version 4. I would hope that in extending it, the beauty of the current GPL is preserved. What is beautiful about the GPL is that it grants the licensee