Re: RFC: removing Mirrors.masterlist from .gitignore in choose-mirror

2013-10-12 Thread Cyril Brulebois
Joey Hess (2013-10-12): > Have you ever looked at the debian-installer source package's network > use? I'm just saying. Fetching packages from the same mirror isn't exactly the same as wgetting a file from an http location without any kind of verification. I'm just saying. src:debian-installer's

Re: RFC: removing Mirrors.masterlist from .gitignore in choose-mirror

2013-10-12 Thread Joey Hess
Cyril Brulebois wrote: > [ Side notes: >1. It's a serious bug to depend on the network; >2. It's also not deterministic to allow failure in doing so. ] Have you ever looked at the debian-installer source package's network use? I'm just saying. If I were throwing arbitrary rules out there,

Re: RFC: removing Mirrors.masterlist from .gitignore in choose-mirror

2013-10-12 Thread Cyril Brulebois
Christian PERRIER (2013-10-12): > Quoting Cyril Brulebois (k...@debian.org): > > > That should ensure we see the need for an update while we're preparing > > the source package, and that we take appropriate measures when that > > happens. What do you think? > > Ack. I'm sure I can still find a w

Re: RFC: removing Mirrors.masterlist from .gitignore in choose-mirror

2013-10-12 Thread Christian PERRIER
Quoting Cyril Brulebois (k...@debian.org): > That should ensure we see the need for an update while we're preparing > the source package, and that we take appropriate measures when that > happens. What do you think? Ack. I'm sure I can still find a way to still fail from time to time but, eh...yo

Re: RFC: removing Mirrors.masterlist from .gitignore in choose-mirror

2013-10-12 Thread Cyril Brulebois
Christian PERRIER (2013-10-12): > That seems fairexcept that, being a frequent uploader of > choose-mirror, I'm very likely to forget about that when building it > then committing back after the build (as I'm building in pbuilder, the > Mirrors.masterlist file in my local git checkout is not u

Re: RFC: removing Mirrors.masterlist from .gitignore in choose-mirror

2013-10-12 Thread Christian PERRIER
Quoting Cyril Brulebois (k...@debian.org): > Hi, > > some background: choose-mirror is a bit special in that it fetches > during the source build (when online) an updated version of the mirror > list[1] and embeds it into the source package. The Said file is > .gitignore'd, meaning it doesn't show

RFC: removing Mirrors.masterlist from .gitignore in choose-mirror

2013-10-11 Thread Cyril Brulebois
Hi, some background: choose-mirror is a bit special in that it fetches during the source build (when online) an updated version of the mirror list[1] and embeds it into the source package. The Said file is .gitignore'd, meaning it doesn't show up in choose-mirror's git repo / history. This also me