Re: [RFC] Alternative implementation for tzsetup (was: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup)

2009-11-22 Thread Christian Perrier
Quoting Frans Pop (elen...@planet.nl): > On Saturday 21 November 2009, Christian Perrier wrote: > > What about "Change language and country"? Even though this is also > > about the locale, I think it's a better approximation of what's being > > done thereand the remains easy to translate. > >

Re: [RFC] Alternative implementation for tzsetup (was: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup)

2009-11-22 Thread Frans Pop
On Saturday 21 November 2009, Christian Perrier wrote: > What about "Change language and country"? Even though this is also > about the locale, I think it's a better approximation of what's being > done thereand the remains easy to translate. Well, the other issue was that it can't be too long

Re: [RFC] Alternative implementation for tzsetup (was: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup)

2009-11-22 Thread Christian Perrier
Quoting Frans Pop (elen...@planet.nl): > P.S. > > How about changing "Choose language" to "Change localization" as menu item > for localechooser? > > A downside could be that that could be difficult to translate for some > languages. IIRC, this was discussed in some way when languagechooser a

Re: [RFC] Alternative implementation for tzsetup (was: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup)

2009-11-21 Thread Frans Pop
On Saturday 21 November 2009, Otavio Salvador wrote: > On Fri, Nov 20, 2009 at 5:16 PM, Frans Pop wrote: > > P.S. > > > > How about changing "Choose language" to "Change localization" as menu > > item for localechooser? > > > > A downside could be that that could be difficult to translate for some

Re: [RFC] Alternative implementation for tzsetup (was: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup)

2009-11-21 Thread Martin Michlmayr
* Otavio Salvador [2009-11-21 10:01]: > Indeed, localization is too techinical IMO. Agreed. -- Martin Michlmayr http://www.cyrius.com/ -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-boot-requ...@lists.debian.org with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact listmas...@lists.debian.org

Re: [RFC] Alternative implementation for tzsetup (was: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup)

2009-11-21 Thread Otavio Salvador
On Fri, Nov 20, 2009 at 5:16 PM, Frans Pop wrote: > P.S. > > How about changing "Choose language" to "Change localization" as menu item > for localechooser? > > A downside could be that that could be difficult to translate for some > languages. Maybe "Choose system language"? Indeed, localizatio

Re: [RFC] Alternative implementation for tzsetup (was: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup)

2009-11-20 Thread Frans Pop
P.S. How about changing "Choose language" to "Change localization" as menu item for localechooser? A downside could be that that could be difficult to translate for some languages. -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-boot-requ...@lists.debian.org with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Cont

Re: [RFC] Alternative implementation for tzsetup (was: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup)

2009-11-20 Thread Frans Pop
On Tuesday 17 November 2009, Frans Pop wrote: > After the decision during yesterday's team meeting I've prepared the > patches to implement the alternative solution to revert the "all > timezones" option and add instead the option to select UTC at medium > priority [1]. > > If there are no objectio

[RFC] Alternative implementation for tzsetup (was: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup)

2009-11-17 Thread Frans Pop
After the decision during yesterday's team meeting I've prepared the patches to implement the alternative solution to revert the "all timezones" option and add instead the option to select UTC at medium priority [1]. If there are no objections before then, I plan to commit these changes on Fri

Re: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup

2009-11-16 Thread Frans Pop
(No need to CC me on list mail.) On Monday 16 November 2009, Ferenc Wagner wrote: > It would be useful to make a list of "things" which must be set up by > the installer, and *then* conceive a set of questions and priorities, > from which these "things" could be derived. Most people working on th

Re: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup

2009-11-16 Thread Ferenc Wagner
Frans Pop writes: > However, it would then be even better to just drop the > tzsetup/selected question and just ask time/zone of everybody, as I > did in my UTC patch. Users in countries with one timezone would then > simply get e.g: > Europe/Amsterdam >

Re: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup

2009-11-16 Thread Frans Pop
On Sunday 15 November 2009, Frans Pop wrote: > I've implemented this at the cost of (only?) 58 lines of code (including > blank lines) and 1 template [1] in localechooser. Although adding this template plus its translations will be a similar size increase as Colin's new template for tzdata, the m

Re: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup

2009-11-15 Thread Frans Pop
On Sunday 15 November 2009, Christian Perrier wrote: > Given the detailed rationale he gave all along this discussion and the > possibilities opened by recent changes to localechooser, I tend to > think that what Frans is proposing is the way to go. > > And I didn't even test the very last image wi

Re: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup

2009-11-15 Thread Christian Perrier
Quoting Christian Perrier (bubu...@debian.org): > I'll try to give a full opinion during the upcoming week-end on this > interesting issue. This will probably involve deep reformulation of > the two different point of views. Hard to do. I spent more time that I was initially planning to work on s

Re: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup

2009-11-15 Thread Frans Pop
On Sunday 15 November 2009, Frans Pop wrote: > Perhaps we could further improve localechooser in that respect by > reusing the shortlist questions to ask what country they'd prefer for > localization if they selected "other" the first time around. That could > be a relatively cheap solution. I've

Re: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup

2009-11-15 Thread Frans Pop
(I'll be dropping private CCs from further replies unless you request them) On Friday 13 November 2009, Colin Watson wrote: > > Right, and this means that you introduce a significant inconsistency > > in the functionality offered to users installing at default prio who > > happen to select a count

Re: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup

2009-11-15 Thread Frans Pop
(I'll be dropping private CCs from further replies unless you request them) On Friday 13 November 2009, Colin Watson wrote: > > Not anymore. With the version of localechooser in SVN and at medium > > priority you can select: > > - English > > - Germany > > - Additional locale en_GB.UTF-8 > > - Def

Re: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup

2009-11-13 Thread Christian Perrier
Quoting Frans Pop (elen...@planet.nl): > From recent commit to tzsetup: I feel the need to mention that, at this point, I've read this entire thread and I'm having hard times making up my mind. I'll try to give a full opinion during the upcoming week-end on this interesting issue. This will prob

Re: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup

2009-11-13 Thread Colin Watson
On Fri, Nov 13, 2009 at 11:01:09AM +0100, Frans Pop wrote: > On Thursday 12 November 2009, Colin Watson wrote: > > No it doesn't. If there's only one choice for the timezone, then you get > > a medium-priority question asking you to confirm your current time, as > > before. The only difference is t

Re: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup

2009-11-13 Thread Colin Watson
On Fri, Nov 13, 2009 at 07:45:48AM +0100, Frans Pop wrote: > On Thursday 12 November 2009, Colin Watson wrote: > > This distinction is not relevant. If I am a speaker of British English > > living in Germany, the only way I can get the behaviour I want is to > > select language English, country Uni

Re: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup

2009-11-13 Thread Frans Pop
On Thursday 12 November 2009, Colin Watson wrote: > > The downside of the merged change is that it means the tzsetup > > selection is now displayed at high priority for *all* users, while in > > the past it would only be displayed for countries that have multiple > > timezones. > > No it doesn't. I

Re: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup

2009-11-12 Thread Frans Pop
On Thursday 12 November 2009, Colin Watson wrote: > This distinction is not relevant. If I am a speaker of British English > living in Germany, the only way I can get the behaviour I want is to > select language English, country United Kingdom, timezone Europe/Berlin. Not anymore. With the version

Re: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup

2009-11-12 Thread Colin Watson
On Thu, Nov 12, 2009 at 02:10:30PM +0100, Frans Pop wrote: > From recent commit to tzsetup: > > + * Merge from Ubuntu: > + - Make it possible to select from a worldwide list of timezones if the > + default list is insufficient, including UTC (closes: #442856). This is > + a bit more gene

Bug#442856: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup

2009-11-12 Thread Frans Pop
On Thursday 12 November 2009, Frans Pop wrote: > While I agree that the option of selecting UTC is worthwhile, I'm not > sure it's worth the raised priority. My suggestion would be to allow UTC > to be preseeded instead, and/or selectable at medium priority. Here's an alternative patch that dynami

Re: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup

2009-11-12 Thread Frans Pop
On Thursday 12 November 2009, Frans Pop wrote: > While I agree that the option of selecting UTC is worthwhile, I'm not > sure it's worth the raised priority. My suggestion would be to allow UTC > to be preseeded instead, and/or selectable at medium priority. Note that preseeding UTC (and setting i

Re: Not sure about recent change in tzsetup

2009-11-12 Thread Frans Pop
On Thursday 12 November 2009, Frans Pop wrote: > I'm particularly unhappy with the added tzsetup/select_all template, > which adds significantly to the size of the udeb. > > IMO is the cost of adding the worldwide list way too high for the very > few cases where it helps users. Because basically, i

Not sure about recent change in tzsetup

2009-11-12 Thread Frans Pop
From recent commit to tzsetup: + * Merge from Ubuntu: + - Make it possible to select from a worldwide list of timezones if the + default list is insufficient, including UTC (closes: #442856). This is + a bit more general than the previous approach suggested by Frans Pop; + my reasoni