Processed: Re: Bug#1036523: should not enable non-free-firmware on virtualized systems

2023-05-22 Thread Debian Bug Tracking System
Processing control commands: > retitle -1 should not install CPU microcode on virtualized systems Bug #1036523 [src:hw-detect] should not enable non-free-firmware on virtualized systems Changed Bug title to 'should not install CPU microcode on virtualized systems' from 'should not enable non-fre

Bug#1036523: should not enable non-free-firmware on virtualized systems

2023-05-22 Thread Cyril Brulebois
Cyril Brulebois (2023-05-22): > I'm willing to consider tweaking (3), making it conditional. […] > Since it's filed at severity normal I think I'll stick to my initial > assessment which was: adjust hw-detect during the Trixie release cycle, > and consider cherry-picks for Bookworm, once we get

Bug#1036523: should not enable non-free-firmware on virtualized systems

2023-05-22 Thread Cyril Brulebois
Control: retitle -1 should not install CPU microcode on virtualized systems Cyril Brulebois (2023-05-22): > For the record: non-free-firmware can be enabled because (1) the kernel logs > firmware requests, (2) available hardware matches modalias information, (3) > CPU matches one with microcode.

Bug#1036523: should not enable non-free-firmware on virtualized systems

2023-05-22 Thread Marco d'Itri
On May 22, Cyril Brulebois wrote: > For the record: non-free-firmware can be enabled because (1) the kernel logs > firmware requests, (2) available hardware matches modalias information, (3) > CPU matches one with microcode. > > (1) and (2) definitely make sense in a virtualized system as well:

Bug#1036523: should not enable non-free-firmware on virtualized systems

2023-05-21 Thread Cyril Brulebois
Hi, Marco d'Itri (2023-05-22): > When bookworm is installed on a virtualized system, the non-free-firmware > component will be enabled even if this is not needed: firmwares cannot be > loaded on virtualized systems because guests usually lack direct access to > the hardware. For the record: non-

Bug#1036523: should not enable non-free-firmware on virtualized systems

2023-05-21 Thread Marco d'Itri
Source: hw-detect Version: 1.155 Severity: normal Tags: d-i When bookworm is installed on a virtualized system, the non-free-firmware component will be enabled even if this is not needed: firmwares cannot be loaded on virtualized systems because guests usually lack direct access to the hardware