Re: [coreboot] [RFC] Successful build with GCC 7.2 and IASL 20170831 for coreboot 4.7

2017-10-02 Thread Williams, Hannah
Hi Matt, Thanks for looking into this. Please submit the patch since you have identified the issue. Thanks Hannah Williams From: Matt DeVillier [mailto:matt.devill...@gmail.com] Sent: Monday, October 2, 2017 8:51 PM To: Paul Menzel Cc: coreboot ; Williams, Hannah Subject: Re: [coreboot] [RFC

[coreboot] Re: 2023-08-23 - coreboot Leadership meeting minutes

2023-08-23 Thread Williams, Hannah
We understand the hesitation to introduce one more binary blob in Coreboot. We are not opposed to open sourcing (we did support libgfxinit for our previous platforms). The Meteor Lake platform is at the final stages of development and validation, so Intel prefers to proceed with the current path

[coreboot] Re: 2023-08-23 - coreboot Leadership meeting minutes

2023-08-24 Thread Williams, Hannah
Hi Sheng, Yes I will come back within the next few weeks on open sourcing uGOP. Hi Nico, I think your suggestion to use similar interface to libgfxinit (gma_gfxinit(), gma_gfxstop()) is a good idea. Please add your comments to the CLs and we will work on it. Regarding the MP PPI and the Kconfi

[coreboot] Re: 2023-08-23 - coreboot Leadership meeting minutes

2023-09-06 Thread Williams, Hannah
Here are the reasons why we cannot open source Meteor Lake uGOP: - It has licensed code for HDMI and other industry specifications (i915 also cannot open source HDMI 2.1) - VBT spec is not open sourced There will have to be a re-design of the uGOP component so that we can work around above issues

[coreboot] Re: 2023-08-23 - coreboot Leadership meeting minutes

2023-09-06 Thread Williams, Hannah
Hi Martin, For laptop form factor, yes only eDP is needed but we do need HDMI for other use cases like Chromebox. It is too late for us to do any cleanup of uGOP for Meteor Lake. I understand that you don't want to include proprietary blobs going forward, but for situations like this where we ca

[coreboot] Re: 2023-08-23 - coreboot Leadership meeting minutes

2023-09-07 Thread Williams, Hannah
Already there are binaries FSP, AGESA, PSP being used in Coreboot and because of IP and licensing issues everything cannot be open sourced. The uGOP is just a stripped down version of GOP that is already inside FSP. This is the fastest method for this specific product and hence we are asking f

[coreboot] Re: 2023-08-23 - coreboot Leadership meeting minutes

2023-09-07 Thread Williams, Hannah
It is not possible to open source uGOP today without re-writing it. We do not have time to re-write considering our product timeline and hence the request to allow to use binary now. We acknowledge that we will make effort to open source uGOP for future SOC by working internally with the other t