Re: [computer-go] computer go documentation issues

2007-03-23 Thread Stuart A. Yeates
On 3/19/07, Roland Illig <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Peter Christopher wrote: > Taking a look at computer go documentation, I see that there are (at > least) three pages that exist in wiki format for top level "computer go" > wiki pages- > > wikipedia.org - computer go > sensei - computer go > se

Re: [computer-go] computer go documentation issues

2007-03-22 Thread Tom Cooper
I agree. The feel of sensei's and wikipedia are completely different. Most of the content on sensei's is too informal for wikipedia, and I think it would get deleted if it was put there, despite this content being very worthwhile. On the other hand, wikipedia is the ideal place for a short autho

Re: [computer-go] computer go documentation issues

2007-03-19 Thread Don Dailey
Sensei and Wikipedia serve somewhat different purposes and I believe they should both be kept up to date. I don't believe the detail of Sensei's Library should be covered by Wikipedia. If I first wanted to get acquainted with some subject I might look it up in an encyclopedia to get an overvie

Re: [computer-go] computer go documentation issues

2007-03-19 Thread Roland Illig
Peter Christopher wrote: Taking a look at computer go documentation, I see that there are (at least) three pages that exist in wiki format for top level "computer go" wiki pages- wikipedia.org - computer go sensei - computer go sensei - computer go programming It seems obvious that these are

Re: [computer-go] computer go documentation issues

2007-03-18 Thread Brian Slesinsky
I think they serve different purposes. Wikipedia has its "no original research" policy meaning that theoretically everything in a Wikipedia article should be backed up by a citation. That's certainly not true now, but it should be a goal. So it seems like there will be lots of details (such as

Re: [computer-go] computer go documentation issues

2007-03-18 Thread Nick Apperson
I fully agree with your plan. Merging it all onto wikipedia seems like a good plan to me. Certainly forwarding the others is a must too. On 3/18/07, Peter Christopher <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Taking a look at computer go documentation, I see that there are (at least) three pages that exist

[computer-go] computer go documentation issues

2007-03-18 Thread Peter Christopher
Taking a look at computer go documentation, I see that there are (at least) three pages that exist in wiki format for top level "computer go" wiki pages- wikipedia.org - computer go sensei - computer go sensei - computer go programming It seems obvious that these are redundant. It seems prud