Re: Getting close to a vote on a merge of S3Guard., HADOOP-13345

2017-08-17 Thread Andrew Wang
Thanks for the reply Steve, aligns what Aaron said above. Sooner the better for this branch merge :) On Thu, Aug 17, 2017 at 6:49 AM, Steve Loughran wrote: > > On 16 Aug 2017, at 18:39, Andrew Wang wrote: > > Hi Steve, > > What's the target release vehicle, and the timeline for merging this? Th

Re: Getting close to a vote on a merge of S3Guard., HADOOP-13345

2017-08-17 Thread Steve Loughran
On 16 Aug 2017, at 18:39, Andrew Wang mailto:andrew.w...@cloudera.com>> wrote: Hi Steve, What's the target release vehicle, and the timeline for merging this? The target date for beta1 is mid-September, so any large code movements make me nervous. Code targets trunk, current state is ready t

Re: Getting close to a vote on a merge of S3Guard., HADOOP-13345

2017-08-16 Thread Andrew Wang
Thanks for the detailed explanation Aaron. Given that this has gone through Cloudera's QA cycle and is run in production, that adds a lot of confidence in the feature. Looking forward to having this in 3.0.0-beta1! Best, Andrew On Wed, Aug 16, 2017 at 2:17 PM, Aaron Fabbri wrote: > > > On Wed,

Re: Getting close to a vote on a merge of S3Guard., HADOOP-13345

2017-08-16 Thread Aaron Fabbri
On Wed, Aug 16, 2017 at 1:39 PM, Andrew Wang wrote: > Hi Steve, > > What's the target release vehicle, and the timeline for merging this? The > target date for beta1 is mid-September, so any large code movements make me > nervous. > I think this is ready to get in before beta1. Most of upstream

Re: Getting close to a vote on a merge of S3Guard., HADOOP-13345

2017-08-16 Thread Andrew Wang
Hi Steve, What's the target release vehicle, and the timeline for merging this? The target date for beta1 is mid-September, so any large code movements make me nervous. Could you comment on testing and API stability of this branch? I'm trusting the judgement of the contributors involved, since th

Getting close to a vote on a merge of S3Guard., HADOOP-13345

2017-08-16 Thread Steve Loughran
FYI, We're getting ready for a patch to merge the current S3Guard branch, HADOOP-13345, via a patch https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/HADOOP-13998 After that's done, we do plan to have a second iteration, work on a 0-rename committer (HADOOP-13786) with all the other tuning and improvements