Re: Google Compute Engine API front-end to CloudStack

2012-06-29 Thread Adrian Cole
I can see two sides to this: 1. it is a distraction: GCE especially an inexperienced api, when we know all new apis change (v1beta12 anyone?) While fun, it implies coding to another spec outside our control (ala) EC2, and implies setting up an OAUTH 2 layer. esp as the current EC2 api isn't

Re: Google Compute Engine API front-end to CloudStack

2012-06-29 Thread David Chamard
I think that google (specially google app engine) has a big developer base that will try/use GCE in the short term. A few 3rd party tools already announced compatibility with GCE. It could be another crowd that will use Cloudstack. David On Fri, Jun 29, 2012 at 8:15 PM, Chiradeep Vittal < chirad

Re: Google Compute Engine API front-end to CloudStack

2012-06-29 Thread Chiradeep Vittal
If I was new to CloudStack / IAAS cloud, it would be a learning experience to map concepts from one cloud implementation to another. See if the abstractions in CloudStack are abstract enough or perhaps they need more refinement. It could attract more folks (GOOG fans) to the CloudStack community.

Re: Google Compute Engine API front-end to CloudStack

2012-06-29 Thread David Nalley
On Fri, Jun 29, 2012 at 8:01 PM, George Reese wrote: > One has an AWS API to take advantage of the AWS ecosystem. No Google > ecosystem exists. > I agree. When/If GCE gets market traction, and the follow on ecosystem tools perhaps it will be time to do it. Aside from that, what is the benefit? (

Re: Google Compute Engine API front-end to CloudStack

2012-06-29 Thread George Reese
One has an AWS API to take advantage of the AWS ecosystem. No Google ecosystem exists. Sent from my iPhone On Jun 29, 2012, at 18:59, Chiradeep Vittal wrote: > Along the lines of the AWS API front-end to CloudStack, would anybody be > interested in developing the GCE front-end? The GCE API [1]

Google Compute Engine API front-end to CloudStack

2012-06-29 Thread Chiradeep Vittal
Along the lines of the AWS API front-end to CloudStack, would anybody be interested in developing the GCE front-end? The GCE API [1] is quite elementary — the most complex piece would be adding an OAuth2 server and integrate that with CloudStack's API key management. GCE maps to basic zone: the