Re: The Santa Claus Problem

2009-05-07 Thread Mark Engelberg
On Wed, May 6, 2009 at 12:38 AM, bOR_ wrote: > If i remember correctly, any agents send (or send-off?) within a > dosync are only send off after the dosync completed. Yes, that's the kind of semantics I want, but it would be rather clunky to have to set up an agent and fake a transformation of i

Re: The Santa Claus Problem

2009-05-06 Thread bOR_
Ah. I guess the elves should be a bit more then just a number, and perhaps be agents themselves, that come to santa with a {:toy :broken} and leave with a {:toy :fixed}, if we want the santa problem to be bit more applicable in reality. What is everyone assuming that the program should do at minim

Re: The Santa Claus Problem

2009-05-06 Thread bOR_
Why isn't this enough for the problem? Elves and deer are entering Santa's frontdoor 1 at a time, when there is three elves in the room, santa instantly deals with them (resetting the number of elves to 0), when there is 9 deer in the room, santa goes sleighing. (def santa (agent {:elves 0 :deer

Re: The Santa Claus Problem

2009-05-06 Thread bOR_
> When writing this code, I found the watcher system a bit clunky to > use, and a bit too heavyweight for what I needed.  Sometimes, within a > dosync block, you want to trigger some sort of side effect once the > current transaction is committed.  To make this easy, I would very > much like to s

Re: The Santa Claus Problem

2009-05-05 Thread Mark Engelberg
I think that part of the point of the Santa Claus problem is to keep everything carefully synchronized. The Erlang and Erlang-inspired solutions are all inherently asynchronous, which means that other threads may be able to observe inconsistencies in state. This problem is compounded if you

Re: The Santa Claus Problem

2009-05-05 Thread Meikel Brandmeyer
Hi, I'm not very familiar with the concurrent features of Clojure myself. So I can't really comment on your solution. I tried to solve the problem myself, though. So here is my try: http://paste.pocoo.org/show/115929 My solution to the "prefer reindeers" problem is a global atom *preparing*. Whi

The Santa Claus Problem

2009-05-05 Thread graham
I thought this problem (described here http://www.cs.otago.ac.nz/staffpriv/ok/santa/) was nifty back when I first encountered Erlang and as a learning exercise I wanted to model something similar in Clojure. I tried to follow the Erlang solution described in the link (http:// www.cs.otago.ac.nz/