Re: [GSoC] Source meta information model proposal

2015-03-20 Thread Ambrose Bonnaire-Sergeant
Hi Christopher, I recommend still sending a proposal for Alex's project just in case. It's hard to predict what constraints we will need to satisfy for project allocation (we might have a small number of allocations from Google, a student may choose a project with another organisation). Thanks, A

Re: [GSoC] Source meta information model proposal

2015-03-20 Thread Christopher Medrela
On Friday, March 20, 2015 at 12:06:34 AM UTC+1, Alex Miller wrote: > > Chris (and anyone else), Daniel mentioned to me in a note that it is ok > for multiple students to submit a proposal for the same project. We do not > know how many spots we will be given as an organization and whether > part

Re: [GSoC] Source meta information model proposal

2015-03-19 Thread Alex Miller
Chris (and anyone else), Daniel mentioned to me in a note that it is ok for multiple students to submit a proposal for the same project. We do not know how many spots we will be given as an organization and whether particular students will meet whatever guidelines are set out by Google. So I thi

Re: [GSoC] Source meta information model proposal

2015-03-19 Thread Reid McKenzie
Found var-link kicking around in my projects dir so I re-published it for this thread. https://github.com/clojure-grimoire/var-link Reid -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Clojure" group. To post to this group, send email to clojure@googlegroups.com N

Re: [GSoC] Source meta information model proposal

2015-03-18 Thread Christopher Medrela
Hello! Alex decided to proceed with Richard. Therefore, I'd like to find some other project. I'm glad to see so much feedback and I'd really like to reply to all your feedback but there is not much time to the end of application period and therefore I will focus exclusively on the another projec

Re: [GSoC] Source meta information model proposal

2015-03-18 Thread richard . moehn
Am Mittwoch, 18. März 2015 07:18:30 UTC+1 schrieb Reid McKenzie: > > Alex, glad to see we're on the same wavelength about this more or less. > > Christopher, some other deliverables worth considering: > Hi all, so I'm the other student Alex mentioned. I'm not participating so much in this dis

Re: [GSoC] Source meta information model proposal

2015-03-17 Thread Reid McKenzie
Alex, glad to see we're on the same wavelength about this more or less. Christopher, some other deliverables worth considering: - What format is documentation in? As Grimoire is evidence, plain doc text is pretty badly formatted on average certainly in comparison to HTML or even markdown.

Re: [GSoC] Source meta information model proposal

2015-03-17 Thread Alex Miller
I'm answering these out of order, sorry. :) On Tuesday, March 17, 2015 at 12:40:53 AM UTC-5, Reid McKenzie wrote: > > Hey Christopher, > > I'm Reid, the Grimoire maintainer. > I'm delighted to see that someone besides myself and Alex is interested in > this project and I wish you the best in your

Re: [GSoC] Source meta information model proposal

2015-03-17 Thread Alex Miller
Hey all, Responding here to several things from both Reid and Francesco. I wanted to step back slightly to set some context. I proposed the project that Chris has posted and some of the points that Reid brought up are really source from my proposal so I wanted to take the blame as it were for

Re: [GSoC] Source meta information model proposal

2015-03-17 Thread Francesco Bellomi
Hi Christopher, I'm Francesco, the maintainer of crossclj.info I think it's a very interesting project. Some comments on your proposal: 1) I think the information model is by far most important deliverable. I agree with Reid that a sound "coordinate system" is very important 2) The toolchain y

Re: [GSoC] Source meta information model proposal

2015-03-16 Thread Reid McKenzie
Hey Christopher, I'm Reid, the Grimoire maintainer. I'm delighted to see that someone besides myself and Alex is interested in this project and I wish you the best in your GSoC application. I'm somewhat concerned in reading your proposal that while you claim the proposed data structure represen

Re: [GSoC] Source meta information model proposal

2015-03-16 Thread Alex Miller
Tom lovingly maintains autodoc and the Clojure projects' automated doc generation with it. But it mostly just continues doing what it does. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Clojure" group. To post to this group, send email to clojure@googlegroups.com

Re: [GSoC] Source meta information model proposal

2015-03-16 Thread Andy Fingerhut
Christopher: I think considering autodoc to be no longer maintained because the last commit was Sep 1 2014 might be a bit hasty. No commits can mean "stable and working", too, not only "abandoned". Tom Faulhaber commits updates to the published Clojure API docs for Clojure itself and its contrib

Re: [GSoC] Source meta information model proposal

2015-03-16 Thread Francis Avila
Wishlist: for macros, metadata about the vars a macro will define. (E.g., (defmacro defrecord [...]) will define (->NAME arg...), (map->NAME m) when executed.) This would allow a lot more source analysis for the common case of def* macros which are just fancy ways of def-ing vars, but without h

[GSoC] Source meta information model proposal

2015-03-16 Thread Christopher Medrela
Hello! My name is Christopher Medrela and I'd like to work at "source metadata information model" project mentored by Alex Miller at Google Summer of Code. I hope that this mailing list is the right place to discuss such projects (if I'm wrong, correct me). I'd like to introduce some standard o