Re: [ceph-users] Software Raid 1 for system disks on storage nodes (not for OSD disks)

2015-09-21 Thread Robert LeBlanc
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA256 Ceph-disk (which ceph-deploy uses), uses GPT to partition OSDs so that they can be automatically started by udev and reference partitions for journals using unique identifiers. The necessary data to start the OSD, the auth key, fsid, etc, are stored

Re: [ceph-users] Software Raid 1 for system disks on storage nodes (not for OSD disks)

2015-09-21 Thread Vickey Singh
On Fri, Sep 18, 2015 at 6:33 PM, Robert LeBlanc wrote: > -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- > Hash: SHA256 > > Depends on how easy it is to rebuild an OS from scratch. If you have > something like Puppet or Chef that configure a node completely for > you, it may not be too much of a pain to forgo

Re: [ceph-users] Software Raid 1 for system disks on storage nodes (not for OSD disks)

2015-09-21 Thread Max A. Krasilnikov
Hello! On Sat, Sep 19, 2015 at 07:03:35AM +0200, martin wrote: > Thanks all for the suggestions. > Our storage nodes have plenty of RAM and their only purpose is to host the > OSD daemons, so we will not create a swap partition on provisioning. As an option, You can use swap file on demand. It

Re: [ceph-users] Software Raid 1 for system disks on storage nodes (not for OSD disks)

2015-09-18 Thread Martin Palma
Thanks all for the suggestions. Our storage nodes have plenty of RAM and their only purpose is to host the OSD daemons, so we will not create a swap partition on provisioning. For the OS disk we will then use a software raid 1 to handle eventually disk failures. For provisioning the hosts we use

Re: [ceph-users] Software Raid 1 for system disks on storage nodes (not for OSD disks)

2015-09-18 Thread Robert LeBlanc
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA256 If you decide to use swap, be warned that significant parts of the OSD code can be swapped out even without memory pressure. This has caused OSD processes to take 5 minutes to shut down in my experience. I would recommend tuning swappiness in this ca

Re: [ceph-users] Software Raid 1 for system disks on storage nodes (not for OSD disks)

2015-09-18 Thread 张冬卯
yes, a raid1 system disk is necessary, from my perspective. And a swap partition is still needed even though the memory is big. Martin Palma mailto:mar...@palma.bz>> 于 2015年9月18日,下午11:07写道:___ ceph-users mailing list ceph-users@lists.ceph.com http://li

Re: [ceph-users] Software Raid 1 for system disks on storage nodes (not for OSD disks)

2015-09-18 Thread Jan Schermer
Hi, > On 18 Sep 2015, at 17:06, Martin Palma wrote: > > Hi, > > Is it a good idea to use a software raid for the system disk (Operating > System) on a Ceph storage node? I mean only for the OS not for the OSD disks. > Yes, absolutely. Or even a hardware RAID if that's what you use elsewhere.

Re: [ceph-users] Software Raid 1 for system disks on storage nodes (not for OSD disks)

2015-09-18 Thread Robert LeBlanc
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA256 Depends on how easy it is to rebuild an OS from scratch. If you have something like Puppet or Chef that configure a node completely for you, it may not be too much of a pain to forgo the RAID. We run our OSD nodes from a single SATADOM and use Puppet

[ceph-users] Software Raid 1 for system disks on storage nodes (not for OSD disks)

2015-09-18 Thread Martin Palma
Hi, Is it a good idea to use a software raid for the system disk (Operating System) on a Ceph storage node? I mean only for the OS not for the OSD disks. And what about a swap partition? Is that needed? Best, Martin ___ ceph-users mailing list ceph-use