Re: [ccp4bb] Bio-rad DuoFlow

2007-02-27 Thread Jan Abendroth
Hi all, joining this discussion late, however, it might worth mentioning that Amersham/GE has phased out the good old FPLC and is no longer providing neither service nor spare parts. Best to my knowledge the same will happen to the Äkta-FPLC system soon leaving the Explorer and Purifier their

Re: [ccp4bb] Bio-rad DuoFlow

2007-02-15 Thread Peter J. Miller
I prefer HPLC too, and am currently using a Waters LC for all my protein purifications. I have also used a Dionex Bio-LC in the past, which does have non-corroding PEEK pump heads. It was a great system. Peter On 2/14/07 8:18 PM, "Daniel Anderson" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > It still seems

Re: [ccp4bb] Bio-rad DuoFlow

2007-02-15 Thread artem
Hi folks, I've been an AKTA user for probably close to ten years, and in this time I've also used BioRad and several other systems. I'd like to make a couple of comments since everyone seems to be enjoying this lively discussion :) 0. Choose the device for what *you* need. Some applications are e

Re: [ccp4bb] Bio-rad DuoFlow

2007-02-14 Thread Dima Klenchin
(FPLC is a trademark. The marketing hype has been so effective that many people think that FPLC is a method.) Well, it is, in a way. The FPLC thingie was a pure marketing genius that bundled the remarkable technology of Monobeads (AFAIK, there is still no other company that offers comparable s

Re: [ccp4bb] Bio-rad DuoFlow

2007-02-14 Thread Daniel Anderson
It still seems to me strange that Bio-Rad would build a machine that can reach pressures suitable for reverse-phase chromatography, but then not include software control for gradual pump acceleration. I tried to communicate to BioRad corporate suits that many HPLC columns are too fragile for abrupt

Re: [ccp4bb] Bio-rad DuoFlow

2007-02-14 Thread William Clemons
In my old lab everyone was slowly converting to Bio-rad for chromatography. We had an Akta and subsequently bought two Bio-rad DuoFlow. I actually never made the conversion then but those that had didn't want to use the Akta anymore. Upon starting my own lab I got quotes for both an Akta an

Re: [ccp4bb] Bio-rad DuoFlow

2007-02-14 Thread Daniel Anderson
That was cryptic. My point was that the BioRad pumps are very reliable given some basic care. Its users quickly learn how to use it, as mentioned previously. On Wed, 14 Feb 2007, Daniel Anderson wrote: > My direct experience is with the old "HR" pumps, but my remarks apply to > the newer "DuoFl

Re: [ccp4bb] Bio-rad DuoFlow

2007-02-14 Thread Daniel Anderson
My direct experience is with the old "HR" pumps, but my remarks apply to the newer "DuoFlow". On Day Zero, I disassemble the pump heads in the order specified in the manual. I re-assemble with grease on the threads, thus preventing expensive repairs due to corrosion of the bolts caused by salty bu

Re: [ccp4bb] Bio-rad DuoFlow

2007-02-14 Thread Tamir Gonen
I beg to differ. I have been an AKTA explorer user for about 5 years and switched to DuoFlow about 4 yrs ago and now have one in my own lab. The BioRad DuoFlow is awesome. It never ever breaks. I never had any problems with this machine at all, it takes any column (pharmacia or otherwise)

[ccp4bb] Bio-rad DuoFlow

2007-02-14 Thread Frank Lee
Dear all, Thanks a lot for all the feedbacks on AKTA prime. They are so helpful that I have abandoned the idea of buying one. Now it is a choice between AKTA FPLC and Bio-rad DuoFlow. I heard that DuoFlow is not as robust as AKTA and that its parts break down often. The question is whether qua