Re: Skipping reminder accidentals in q

2014-07-13 Thread James
On 13/07/14 15:21, David Kastrup wrote: > James writes: > >> On 13/07/14 11:49, David Kastrup wrote: >>> Helge Kruse writes: >>> Am 13.07.2014 11:57, schrieb David Kastrup: > 4q > Well, just write the latter version. Well. this means "don't use q when you have accid

Re: Skipping reminder accidentals in q

2014-07-13 Thread Kieren MacMillan
Hi David, > At some point of time, one just has to accept that q is a shorthand. > Once it becomes hard figuring out the proper semantics, we are leaving > the shorthand realm. Point taken… But to imply that coming up with a logically consistent interpretation of each possibility is disingenuou

Re: Skipping reminder accidentals in q

2014-07-13 Thread David Kastrup
Kieren MacMillan writes: > Hi all, > >> "chord repeats should not repeat forced/cautionary accidentals". That’s >> pretty straightforward. > > Of course [because it’s 'common sense’], I agree this should be the default > behaviour… > But I think it would be nice if there were still a way to ov

Re: Skipping reminder accidentals in q

2014-07-13 Thread Kieren MacMillan
Hi all, > "chord repeats should not repeat forced/cautionary accidentals". That’s > pretty straightforward. Of course [because it’s 'common sense’], I agree this should be the default behaviour… But I think it would be nice if there were still a way to override that, e.g., q! and q? to repeat

Re: Skipping reminder accidentals in q

2014-07-13 Thread David Kastrup
James writes: > On 13/07/14 11:49, David Kastrup wrote: >> Helge Kruse writes: >> >>> Am 13.07.2014 11:57, schrieb David Kastrup: >>> 4q Well, just write the latter version. >>> Well. this means "don't use q when you have accidentals in a chord". >> Reminder or forced accidenta

Re: Skipping reminder accidentals in q

2014-07-13 Thread James
On 13/07/14 11:49, David Kastrup wrote: > Helge Kruse writes: > >> Am 13.07.2014 11:57, schrieb David Kastrup: >> >>> 4q >>> Well, just write the latter version. >> Well. this means "don't use q when you have accidentals in a chord". > Reminder or forced accidentals, it would appear. > >>