Re: Issue 2270 in lilypond: Feature request: cross-staff chords

2012-03-17 Thread lilypond
Comment #3 on issue 2270 by m...@apollinemike.com: Feature request: cross-staff chords http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=2270 This would be a major project. Pavel has already implemented a workaround for common cases in Scheme, but a holistic and automated solution would

Re: Issue 2270 in lilypond: Feature request: cross-staff chords

2012-03-17 Thread lilypond
Updates: Labels: Bounty Comment #2 on issue 2270 by julien.r...@gmail.com: Feature request: cross-staff chords http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=2270 Let's give the bounty hunters a hint. ___ bug-lilypond mailing lis

Re: Issue 2270 in lilypond: Feature request: cross-staff chords

2012-02-02 Thread lilypond
Comment #1 on issue 2270 by paconet@gmail.com: Feature request: cross-staff chords http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=2270 MS has announced a patch that implements a barebones version. This is to remind that I have promised 50 EUR to reward this feature

Re: Feature request: cross-staff chords

2012-02-01 Thread Marek Klein
Hello, 2012/1/31 Pavel Roskin > In my opinion, Lilypond should be able to support chords with noteheads on > different staves. This is especially important within staff groups for > keyboard instruments. > This has been added as http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=2270. Marek Kl

Issue 2270 in lilypond: Feature request: cross-staff chords

2012-02-01 Thread lilypond
Status: Accepted Owner: Labels: Type-Enhancement New issue 2270 by ma...@gregoriana.sk: Feature request: cross-staff chords http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=2270 By Pavel Roskin: http://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/bug-lilypond/2012-01/msg01274.html In my opinion, Lilypond

Re: Feature request: cross-staff chords

2012-02-01 Thread Pavel Roskin
On Tue, 31 Jan 2012 21:27:37 +0100 "m...@apollinemike.com" wrote: > I have a patch that implements a barebones version of this that I > haven't tinkered with for some time because of the issue of > NoteCollision grobs. That's great news! I'm looking forward seeing it on the issue page. Even an

Re: Feature request: cross-staff chords

2012-01-31 Thread Francisco Vila
2012/1/31 m...@apollinemike.com : > Hey all, > > I have a patch that implements a barebones version of this that I haven't > tinkered with for some time because of the issue of NoteCollision grobs. > > NoteCollision grobs shift notes around so that they do not collide.  They > would assumedly nee

Re: Feature request: cross-staff chords

2012-01-31 Thread m...@apollinemike.com
On Jan 31, 2012, at 9:14 PM, Francisco Vila wrote: > 2012/1/31 Pavel Roskin : >>> Various users have requested the same in the past. >> >> I know. Perhaps it's time to have an issue in the bug tracker. > > Definitely. > >> Once there is an issue in the tracker, it should be possible to attach

Re: Feature request: cross-staff chords

2012-01-31 Thread Francisco Vila
2012/1/31 Pavel Roskin : >> Various users have requested the same in the past. > > I know.  Perhaps it's time to have an issue in the bug tracker. Definitely. > Once there is an issue in the tracker, it should be possible to attach > bounties to it. I would add an amount to that, for I'm interes

Re: Feature request: cross-staff chords

2012-01-31 Thread Pavel Roskin
On Tue, 31 Jan 2012 18:02:35 +0100 Francisco Vila wrote: > 2012/1/31 Pavel Roskin : > > In my opinion, Lilypond should be able to support chords with > > noteheads on different staves.  This is especially important within > > staff groups for keyboard instruments. > > It is not easy. This is the

Re: Feature request: cross-staff chords

2012-01-31 Thread Francisco Vila
2012/1/31 Pavel Roskin : > In my opinion, Lilypond should be able to support chords with noteheads on > different staves.  This is especially important within staff groups for > keyboard instruments. It is not easy. This is the closest we are to a flexible solution nowadays: \new PianoStaff <<

Feature request: cross-staff chords

2012-01-31 Thread Pavel Roskin
Hello! In my opinion, Lilypond should be able to support chords with noteheads on different staves. This is especially important within staff groups for keyboard instruments. Lilypond can already move a voice from one staff to another. It can connect notes on different staves with beams