Re: \lyricsto ruins sequential lyrics

2017-09-04 Thread David Kastrup
James writes: > On Mon, 04 Sep 2017 08:38:02 +0200 > David Kastrup wrote: > >> Dan Eble writes: >> >> > So difficult to do anything about that it’s not worth tracking. >> > Very well. >> >> I don't know whether we have an issue entry for this or not. > > No I don't think we do. If we did

Re: \lyricsto ruins sequential lyrics

2017-09-04 Thread James
On Mon, 04 Sep 2017 08:38:02 +0200 David Kastrup wrote: > Dan Eble writes: > > > So difficult to do anything about that it’s not worth tracking. > > Very well. > > I don't know whether we have an issue entry for this or not. No I don't think we do. James

Re: \lyricsto ruins sequential lyrics

2017-09-03 Thread David Kastrup
Dan Eble writes: > So difficult to do anything about that it’s not worth tracking. > Very well. I don't know whether we have an issue entry for this or not. But you still have the logical problem that a \lyricsto context can only end when the _next_ music expression has been encountered and the

Re: \lyricsto ruins sequential lyrics

2017-09-03 Thread Dan Eble
So difficult to do anything about that it’s not worth tracking. Very well. — Dan ___ bug-lilypond mailing list bug-lilypond@gnu.org https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/bug-lilypond

Re: \lyricsto ruins sequential lyrics

2017-09-03 Thread Dan Eble
On Sep 3, 2017, at 08:42, Thomas Morley wrote: > still not sure I really understood what you are after... > Though, how about below? > Admittedly, it's only the sketch of an idea, but seems to work > > music = > \new Voice = "m" \repeat volta 2 \relative c'' { c4 c8 c c4 c } > > lyrI = \lyricmod

Re: \lyricsto ruins sequential lyrics

2017-09-03 Thread David Kastrup
Dan Eble writes: > Simon wrote: >> On 02.09.2017 23:11, Dan Eble wrote: >>> David wrote: Putting different lyrics in sequence to each other does not make a lot of sense, >>> Isn’t it fundamental to performing a multi-stanza song? >> >> Different lyrics _contexts_ in sequence don’t m

Re: \lyricsto ruins sequential lyrics

2017-09-03 Thread Thomas Morley
2017-09-03 1:14 GMT+02:00 Dan Eble : > I hope this example makes clear what I’m trying to do. Below is the input, > and attached is what a MIDI editor shows of the output. (I hope it comes > through.) In the output, \unfoldRepeats has unfolded the notes into two > measures, but the lyrics are

Re: \lyricsto ruins sequential lyrics

2017-09-03 Thread Phil Holmes
"Dan Eble" wrote in message news:c474df11-0db5-41ec-8e4b-abc890c5b...@faithful.be... [copying the bug list this time—sorry] David wrote: Putting different lyrics in sequence to each other does not make a lot of sense, Isn’t it fundamental to performing a multi-stanza song? This is how I do

Re: \lyricsto ruins sequential lyrics

2017-09-03 Thread Dan Eble
Simon wrote: > On 02.09.2017 23:11, Dan Eble wrote: >> David wrote: >>> Putting different lyrics in sequence to each other does not make a lot of >>> sense, >> Isn’t it fundamental to performing a multi-stanza song? > > Different lyrics _contexts_ in sequence don’t make a lot of sense. Yet t

Re: \lyricsto ruins sequential lyrics

2017-09-02 Thread Simon Albrecht
On 02.09.2017 23:11, Dan Eble wrote: [copying the bug list this time—sorry] David wrote: Putting different lyrics in sequence to each other does not make a lot of sense, Isn’t it fundamental to performing a multi-stanza song? Different lyrics _contexts_ in sequence don’t make a lot of sense.

Re: \lyricsto ruins sequential lyrics

2017-09-02 Thread Dan Eble
I hope this example makes clear what I’m trying to do. Below is the input, and attached is what a MIDI editor shows of the output. (I hope it comes through.) In the output, \unfoldRepeats has unfolded the notes into two measures, but the lyrics are still concurrent in the first measure (natur

Re: \lyricsto ruins sequential lyrics

2017-09-02 Thread Dan Eble
[copying the bug list this time—sorry] David wrote: > Putting different lyrics in sequence to each other does not make a lot of > sense, Isn’t it fundamental to performing a multi-stanza song? > and a \lyricsto-governed context in > particular has no well-defined ending where another context co

Re: \lyricsto ruins sequential lyrics

2017-09-02 Thread David Kastrup
Dan Eble writes: > %% It is puzzling that none of cases 2-4 produces the same output as > %% case 1. I could not find any known issue in the NR that would > %% explain this. > %% > %% Case 2 is extra puzzling because Lilypond warns that the syllables > %% in { Cc2 Dd } are simultaneous. > \versi

\lyricsto ruins sequential lyrics

2017-09-02 Thread Dan Eble
%% It is puzzling that none of cases 2-4 produces the same output as %% case 1. I could not find any known issue in the NR that would %% explain this. %% %% Case 2 is extra puzzling because Lilypond warns that the syllables %% in { Cc2 Dd } are simultaneous. \version "2.18.0" music = \relative c'