Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-17 Thread Almudena Garcia
> But then it has its own bugs, which will be much easier to track down in kvm. Ok, wait that my information makes useful El mar, 17 ago 2021 a las 20:03, Samuel Thibault () escribió: > Almudena Garcia, le mar. 17 août 2021 19:49:11 +0200, a ecrit: > > Ok, then I will regret to compatibility mode

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-17 Thread Samuel Thibault
Almudena Garcia, le mar. 17 août 2021 19:49:11 +0200, a ecrit: > Ok, then I will regret to compatibility mode. I was interested to check if the > new SATA AHCI driver is able to work in a real machine Well, apparently it does work indeed. But then it has its own bugs, which will be much easier to

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-17 Thread Almudena Garcia
Ok, then I will regret to compatibility mode. I was interested to check if the new SATA AHCI driver is able to work in a real machine Thanks for your help El mar, 17 ago 2021 a las 19:38, Samuel Thibault () escribió: > Almudena Garcia, le mar. 17 août 2021 19:19:34 +0200, a ecrit: > > In rescue

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-17 Thread Samuel Thibault
Almudena Garcia, le mar. 17 août 2021 19:19:34 +0200, a ecrit: > In rescue mode, I tried to reinstall GRUB in /dev/wd0s1, but It seems that > GRUB > don't find the disk. Yes, confusingly grub always calls disks hd0, hd1, etc, whether it is AHCI, IDE, SCSI or whatever. > Although the rescue mode

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-17 Thread Samuel Thibault
Almudena Garcia, le mar. 17 août 2021 18:49:07 +0200, a ecrit: > Ok, the change of naming to /dev/sd0s1 in fstab failed. The boot continues > using the device /dev/hd0s1 That will be solved by an update-grub call. But again, it's completely useless to look at this, as long as sd0 is not actually

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-17 Thread Sergey Bugaev
On Tue, Aug 17, 2021 at 7:44 PM Almudena Garcia wrote: > But, in fstab, the drives are registered as /dev/hd0s1 (root partition in > harddisk), and /dev/hd2 (cdron drive). > I can try to change them to sdX naming, but is a bit risky fstab only comes into play later in the boot process (certainly

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-17 Thread Samuel Thibault
Almudena Garcia, le mar. 17 août 2021 18:43:38 +0200, a ecrit: > But, in fstab, the drives are registered as /dev/hd0s1 (root partition in > harddisk), and /dev/hd2 (cdron drive). Yes, because that was how it was during the debian installer. Think the BIOS compatibility/AHCI switch as "I unplug th

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-17 Thread Almudena Garcia
Ok, the change of naming to /dev/sd0s1 in fstab failed. The boot continues using the device /dev/hd0s1 El mar, 17 ago 2021 a las 18:43, Almudena Garcia (< liberamenso10...@gmail.com>) escribió: > But, in fstab, the drives are registered as /dev/hd0s1 (root partition in > harddisk), and /dev/hd2 (

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-17 Thread Almudena Garcia
But, in fstab, the drives are registered as /dev/hd0s1 (root partition in harddisk), and /dev/hd2 (cdron drive). I can try to change them to sdX naming, but is a bit risky El mar, 17 ago 2021 a las 18:33, Samuel Thibault () escribió: > Almudena Garcia, le mar. 17 août 2021 18:26:24 +0200, a ecrit

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-17 Thread Samuel Thibault
Almudena Garcia, le mar. 17 août 2021 18:26:24 +0200, a ecrit: > Really, there are not any sd0 device, I think. Really, in AHCI mode, yes, it is to be sd0, not hd0. hd0 is only in IDE mode. > But the SATA driver search this sdX device The SATA driver doesn't search for sdX, it *provides* sdX. W

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-17 Thread Almudena Garcia
Really, there are not any sd0 device, I think. The harddisk is hd0. But the SATA driver search this sdX device El mar, 17 ago 2021 a las 18:20, Samuel Thibault () escribió: > Almudena Garcia, le mar. 17 août 2021 18:02:49 +0200, a ecrit: > > I tried, but not boot. > > Well that was expected since

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-17 Thread Samuel Thibault
Almudena Garcia, le mar. 17 août 2021 18:02:49 +0200, a ecrit: > I tried, but not boot. Well that was expected since it's the same kernel as in the debian installer. > I attach some images > ahci: 00:1f.2: Port 0 communication not established. TODO: power on device > sd0: timeout waiting for re

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-17 Thread Samuel Thibault
Almudena Garcia, le mar. 17 août 2021 16:02:55 +0200, a ecrit: > The installation in compatibily mode works correctly, the fail in with the > installation in AHCI mode, which fails after partition step Now that you have it installed in compatibily mode, could you try to boot it in AHCI mode, to se

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-17 Thread Almudena Garcia
The installation in compatibily mode works correctly, the fail in with the installation in AHCI mode, which fails after partition step El mar, 17 ago 2021 a las 16:01, Almudena Garcia (< liberamenso10...@gmail.com>) escribió: > > You need to select "AHCI" in bios - not "Compatibility"! > I did it

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-16 Thread Damien Zammit
Hi Almu, You need to select "AHCI" in bios - not "Compatibility"! "lspci -nn" on my w520 with coreboot shows: 00:1f.2 SATA controller [0106]: Intel Corporation 6 Series/C200 Series Chipset Family 6 port Mobile SATA AHCI Controller [8086:1c03] (rev 05) I think the compatibility mode makes it ap

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-16 Thread Samuel Thibault
Almudena Garcia, le lun. 16 août 2021 23:05:59 +0200, a ecrit: > Ok. Tomorrow I will repeat the test in a T60 or similar model, older than > this, > which probably use 32-bit busses. I don't think that's the problem. And we want to fix the problem anyway. Samuel

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-16 Thread Almudena Garcia
Ok. Tomorrow I will repeat the test in a T60 or similar model, older than this, which probably use 32-bit busses. I will report the results El lun, 16 ago 2021 a las 22:45, Samuel Thibault () escribió: > Almudena Garcia, le lun. 16 août 2021 22:19:15 +0200, a ecrit: > > > And with -v ? > > Check

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-16 Thread Samuel Thibault
Almudena Garcia, le lun. 16 août 2021 22:19:15 +0200, a ecrit: > > And with -v ? > Check attached image Ok, so it does say that it provides the AHCI interface. I don't know why gnumach doesn't pick it up then, investigation is needed with actually gnumach messages, possibly adding more printfs in

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-16 Thread Almudena Garcia
> And with -v ? Check attached image El lun, 16 ago 2021 a las 22:03, Samuel Thibault () escribió: > Almudena Garcia, le lun. 16 août 2021 21:40:13 +0200, a ecrit: > > lspci -n results > > And with -v ? > > Note that I'm wondering about the so-called AHCI mode, not the > IDE-compatible mode which

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-16 Thread Samuel Thibault
Almudena Garcia, le lun. 16 août 2021 21:40:13 +0200, a ecrit: > lspci -n results And with -v ? Note that I'm wondering about the so-called AHCI mode, not the IDE-compatible mode which shows an IDE interface that, as you have experienced, gnumach is fine with. Samuel

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-16 Thread Samuel Thibault
Almudena Garcia, le lun. 16 août 2021 21:41:17 +0200, a ecrit: > The installer detects the size correctly That doesn't mean that drivers can actually write that far. Samuel

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-16 Thread Almudena Garcia
The installer detects the size correctly El lun, 16 ago 2021 a las 21:38, Samuel Thibault () escribió: > Almudena Garcia, le lun. 16 août 2021 20:47:02 +0200, a ecrit: > > > Alternatively you could try to reboot to have the partition re-read. > But > > > still it's not expected that partition re-

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-16 Thread Almudena Garcia
lspci -n results El lun, 16 ago 2021 a las 21:36, Samuel Thibault () escribió: > It's lspci -n that we need, to be able to know exactly what this is. > Otherwise it's about randomly grepping in pci.ids to divine what that > could actually be. > > Samuel >

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-16 Thread Samuel Thibault
Almudena Garcia, le lun. 16 août 2021 20:47:02 +0200, a ecrit: > > Alternatively you could try to reboot to have the partition re-read. But > > still it's not expected that partition re-read doesn't work, it is > > implemented and works in my tests. As usual, actual error messages are > > what you

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-16 Thread Samuel Thibault
It's lspci -n that we need, to be able to know exactly what this is. Otherwise it's about randomly grepping in pci.ids to divine what that could actually be. Samuel

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-16 Thread Almudena Garcia
And another lspci from the installer in AHCI mode El lun, 16 ago 2021 a las 21:17, Almudena Garcia (< liberamenso10...@gmail.com>) escribió: > Another lspci from Manjaro Linux in live mode, enabling AHCI in BIOS > > > > > > El lun, 16 ago 2021 a las 21:11, Almudena Garcia (< > liberamenso10...@gm

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-16 Thread Almudena Garcia
> Is it really in AHCI mode? Yes, I enabled AHCI SATA mode in the BIOS > This is talking about wd0, i.e. the rumpdisk device, i.e. gnumach > didn't detect the AHCI card. That's not expected, we need to know what > is actually showing up exactly in lspci, to be sure that the card is > showing up r

Re: Problems trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in SATA AHCI mode, over Thinkpad T410

2021-08-16 Thread Samuel Thibault
Hello, Almudena Garcia, le dim. 15 août 2021 02:04:38 +0200, a ecrit: > Tonight I'm trying to install Debian GNU/Hurd 2021 in a Thinkpad T410, > configuring SATA disk in AHCI mode, Is it really in AHCI mode? > The installer loads, but in partitioning step, after format the partitions, I > found