Re: gnulib-tool and autoreconf

2008-12-07 Thread Ralf Wildenhues
Hi Bruno, * Bruno Haible wrote on Sun, Dec 07, 2008 at 05:33:38PM CET: > > > It would seem odd to have 'autoreconf' invoke 'gnulib-tool'. gnulib-tool > > > is a tool that *fetches* source files, whereas autoreconf is a tool that > > > *combines* source files, generating additional files from them.

Re: gnulib-tool and autoreconf

2008-12-07 Thread Bruno Haible
Hello Ralf, > > It would seem odd to have 'autoreconf' invoke 'gnulib-tool'. gnulib-tool > > is a tool that *fetches* source files, whereas autoreconf is a tool that > > *combines* source files, generating additional files from them. > > Therefore gnulib-tool logically belongs before autoreconf. >

Re: gnulib-tool and autoreconf

2008-12-07 Thread Bruno Haible
Eric Blake wrote: > I think it is the existence, and proper maintenance, of m4 > serial numbers that will make your proposed change to autopoint worthwhile. Yes, the serial numbers will matter now. > > Therefore I would find it better if autopoint had an option that tells it > > not to overwrite

Re: gnulib-tool and autoreconf

2008-12-07 Thread Ralf Wildenhues
Hello Bruno, * Bruno Haible wrote on Sat, Dec 06, 2008 at 11:18:05AM CET: > It would seem odd to have 'autoreconf' invoke 'gnulib-tool'. gnulib-tool > is a tool that *fetches* source files, whereas autoreconf is a tool that > *combines* source files, generating additional files from them. > Theref

Re: gnulib-tool and autoreconf

2008-12-06 Thread Eric Blake
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 According to Bruno Haible on 12/6/2008 3:18 AM: > It would seem odd to have 'autoreconf' invoke 'gnulib-tool'. gnulib-tool > is a tool that *fetches* source files, whereas autoreconf is a tool that > *combines* source files, generating additional files

Re: gnulib-tool and autoreconf

2008-12-06 Thread Bruno Haible
Colin Watson wrote: > I find the advice in gnulib's documentation "Caveat: gettextize and > autopoint users" rather difficult to follow in practice. I prefer to use > autoreconf rather than having to track which tools and options I'm > supposed to be using, but autoreconf invokes autopoint followed

Re: gnulib-tool and autoreconf

2008-11-18 Thread Eric Blake
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 [adding autoconf list] According to Colin Watson on 11/18/2008 3:35 AM: > I find the advice in gnulib's documentation "Caveat: gettextize and > autopoint users" rather difficult to follow in practice. I prefer to use > autoreconf rather than having to

Re: gnulib-tool and autoreconf

2008-11-18 Thread Simon Josefsson
Colin Watson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > I find the advice in gnulib's documentation "Caveat: gettextize and > autopoint users" rather difficult to follow in practice. I prefer to use > autoreconf rather than having to track which tools and options I'm > supposed to be using, but autoreconf invo

gnulib-tool and autoreconf

2008-11-18 Thread Colin Watson
I find the advice in gnulib's documentation "Caveat: gettextize and autopoint users" rather difficult to follow in practice. I prefer to use autoreconf rather than having to track which tools and options I'm supposed to be using, but autoreconf invokes autopoint followed by the other tools without