On Wed, Jun 3, 2015 at 10:33 AM, Stephen Morse
wrote:
> Pindar,
>
> yes and it's a good idea to separate the hard/soft fork upgrades. The
>> point being here is that we're also establishing a process for the
>> community to self-determine the way forward in a transparent and verifiable
>> manner.
Some changes:
Votes need to be 100%, not 50.01%. That way small miners have a fair
chance. A 50.01% vote means large miners call the shots.
Users (people who make transactions) need to vote. A vote by a miner
shouldn't count without user votes. Fee incentives should attract
legitimate votes from
Vincent,
> Some changes:
>
> Votes need to be 100%, not 50.01%. That way small miners have a fair
> chance. A 50.01% vote means large miners call the shots.
>
While I like the idea of possibly requiring more than 50%, you wouldn't
want to have a situation where a minority of uncooperative (or just
Pindar,
yes and it's a good idea to separate the hard/soft fork upgrades. The point
> being here is that we're also establishing a process for the community to
> self-determine the way forward in a transparent and verifiable manner.
>
> What's not to like? :)
>
> I'll probably have some time on Su
>
> Why do it as an OP_RETURN output? It could be a simple token in the
> coinbase input script, similar to how support for P2SH was signaled among
> miners. And why should there be an explicit token for voting for the status
> quo? Simply omitting any indication should be an implicit vote for the
Why do it as an OP_RETURN output? It could be a simple token in the coinbase
input script, similar to how support for P2SH was signaled among miners. And
why should there be an explicit token for voting for the status quo? Simply
omitting any indication should be an implicit vote for the status
This is likely very similar to other proposals, but I want to bring voting
procedures back into the discussion. The goal here is to create a voting
procedure that is as simple as possible to increase the block size limit.
Votes are aggregated over each 2016 block period. Each coinbase transaction
7 matches
Mail list logo
