Re: [bitcoin-dev] Meeting Summary & Logs for CTV Meeting #5

2022-03-10 Thread Jorge Timón via bitcoin-dev
Thank you for explaining. I agree with luke then, I'm against speedy trial. I explained why already, I think. In summary: speedy trial kind of means is miners and not users who decide the rules. It gives users less opportunities to react and oppose a malevolent change in case miners want to impose

Re: [bitcoin-dev] Meeting Summary & Logs for CTV Meeting #5

2022-03-09 Thread ZmnSCPxj via bitcoin-dev
Good morning Jorge, > What is ST? If it may be a reason to oppose CTV, why not talk about it more > explicitly so that others can understand the criticisms? ST is Speedy Trial. Basically, a short softfork attempt with `lockinontimeout=false` is first done. If this fails, then developers stop and

Re: [bitcoin-dev] Meeting Summary & Logs for CTV Meeting #5

2022-03-09 Thread Jorge Timón via bitcoin-dev
What is ST? If it may be a reason to oppose CTV, why not talk about it more explicitly so that others can understand the criticisms? It seems that criticism isn't really that welcomed and is just explained away. Perhaps it is just my subjective perception. Sometimes it feels we're going from "don't