Re: [bitcoin-dev] Draft-BIP: Ordinal Numbers

2022-02-24 Thread damian--- via bitcoin-dev
Not all people who have been stolen from believe that they have lost the right and title to what has been stolen and in many cases they have not. I do not excuse Bitcoin that it is impossible to have any individual Bitcoin identified but also I do not care, if I receive Bitcoin honestly I do no

Re: [bitcoin-dev] Draft-BIP: Ordinal Numbers

2022-02-23 Thread damian--- via bitcoin-dev
At the moment it is indisputable that a particular satoshi cannot be proven, an amount of Bitcoin is a bag of satoshi's and no-one can tell which ones are any particular ones **so even if you used the system of ordinals privately, and it might make interesting for research, I cannot see that it

Re: [bitcoin-dev] Draft-BIP: Ordinal Numbers

2022-02-23 Thread damian--- via bitcoin-dev
Well done, your bip looks well presented for discussion. You say to number each satoshi created? For a 50 BTC block reward that is 5,000,000,000 ordinal numbers, and when some BTC is transferred to another UTXO how do you determine which ordinal numbers, say if I create a transaction to pay-to

Re: [bitcoin-dev] Proposal: Full-RBF in Bitcoin Core 24.0

2021-12-20 Thread damian--- via bitcoin-dev
Good Afternoon, There is no such thing in Bitcoin as zeroconf but any individual may use gossip from mempool if they choose it to prefer it could be possible a transaction could exist in the future. You are talking about the mempool. The mempool exists on gossip. There are no transactions unti

Re: [bitcoin-dev] Rebroadcast mechanism in Bitcoin P2P network

2021-12-12 Thread damian--- via bitcoin-dev
Good Afternoon, You are right, of course, I did nothing to differentiate between the privacy of the connection of the node, the identification of the public IP of the node, and the suspected original of a transaction. If I understand, the reason for only the originating node to rebroadcast w

Re: [bitcoin-dev] Rebroadcast mechanism in Bitcoin P2P network

2021-12-11 Thread damian--- via bitcoin-dev
Good Afternoon, Thank-you for your good work cataloguing and writing about the contributions to Bitcoin. It is that the solution to privacy is to use privacy-enhancing network communications, such as TOR. I am not against a mechanism to rebroadcast transactions more robustly if the mempool o

Re: [bitcoin-dev] [Lightning-dev] Take 2: Removing the Dust Limit

2021-12-09 Thread damian--- via bitcoin-dev
Good Afternoon, 'Avoiding a soft-fork' is a political concession. Consensus is none of that. KING JAMES HRMH Great British Empire Regards, The Australian LORD HIS EXCELLENCY JAMES HRMH (& HMRH) of Hougun Manor & Glencoe & British Empire MR. Damian A. James Williamson Wills et al. Willtech

Re: [bitcoin-dev] bitcoin.org missing bitcoin core version 22.0

2021-11-05 Thread damian--- via bitcoin-dev
Good Afternoon, Talk about the present and the future is misguided if it concludes that the decentralisation of a project itself is responsible even if the operation of the project is to produce a specification, and a software capable of performing transactions in a decentralised manner. There

Re: [bitcoin-dev] Year 2038 problem and year 2106 chain halting

2021-10-18 Thread damian--- via bitcoin-dev
Good Afternoon, I am certain that as soon as we identify solutions they should be implemented. Basic life skills assert that procrastination is always a form of failure, where we could have realised and accomplished further yet we waited and in our present state could not ascertain what was in