Re: [bitcoin-dev] Generalised Replay Protection for Future Hard Forks

2017-11-08 Thread Mats Jerratsch via bitcoin-dev
Hey Jacob! > Take the specific and common case of non-upgraded wallet software. Suppose a > HF happens, and becomes the network used by 90% of users. Will old wallets > still default to the old nForkId (10% legacy chain)? If so, I'd expect a lot > of accidental mis-sends on that chain. With

Re: [bitcoin-dev] Centralizing mining by force

2017-11-08 Thread ZmnSCPxj via bitcoin-dev
Good morning Robert, What you describe is precisely one possible result of a 51% attack. At below the 50% threshold, miners outside the cartel will on average outrace miners inside the cartel, so fullnodes which do not follow cartel rules will reject them as per Nakamoto Consensus. At some poi

Re: [bitcoin-dev] Centralizing mining by force

2017-11-08 Thread Marc Bevand via bitcoin-dev
What you describe is an example of a majority attack ("51% attack"). No technical mechanism in Bitcoin prevents this. However in practice, miners are not incentivized to perform this attack as it would destroy confidence in Bitcoin, and would ultimately impact their revenues. -Marc On Mon, Nov 6,