Re: bgp sorted tables

2018-10-18 Thread Maria Jan Matějka
>other implementations has no problems with sorted output, even for >hundreds thousands of routes in table. That is not my problem, nor a valid argument at all. By the way, when writing about significantly slower output, it still does not mean any problems like getting BIRD stuck or bloated.

Re: bgp sorted tables

2018-10-18 Thread Daniel Suchy
Hello, other implementations has no problems with sorted output, even for hundreds thousands of routes in table. It also can be implemented as a some configuration option or as a command parameter (something like "show ... sorted"), if you're worry about significant performance degradation. Unsor

Re: bgp sorted tables

2018-10-18 Thread Maria Jan Matějka
On October 18, 2018 10:44:36 AM GMT+02:00, Daniel Suchy wrote: >Hello, >I think sorting should not be limited only to "show routes" output. Beware. The sorted output may be significantly slower than the unsorted. The unsorted route list will remain the default. >Also >other show commands n

Re: bgp sorted tables

2018-10-18 Thread Daniel Suchy
Hello, I think sorting should not be limited only to "show routes" output. Also other show commands needs to be sorted in human-readable order (like show protocols, show bfd sessions etc). In large-scale deployments (like IXP route-servers, where you're also have limited commands available within l

Re: bgp sorted tables

2018-10-18 Thread Milen Bogunski
-users@network.cz Sent: Thu, 18 Oct 2018 11:04:08 +0200 Subject: Re: bgp sorted tables > Hi! > > The sorted keyword is used for sorting different routes for the same prefix > to be available for the first-pass-the-filter exports. This should work and > we aren't aware about an

Re: bgp sorted tables

2018-10-18 Thread Maria Jan Matějka
Hi! The sorted keyword is used for sorting different routes for the same prefix to be available for the first-pass-the-filter exports. This should work and we aren't aware about any changes that could break it. If you have a reproducer, please share it with us to be able to debug it. I suspec

bgp sorted tables

2018-10-18 Thread Milen Bogunski
Hello, I'm trying to use sorted table feature (despite it is described as a little bit slower) I'm trying on 1.6.3, 1.6.4 with table master sorted; also on 2.0.2 format ipv4 table master4 sorted; But is does not seem to work, when show route from birdc routes are still in random order. anyone