Re: One bird VM (HA cluster) or two bird VMs (iBGP).

2025-03-18 Thread Mike Neo
Assuming that these will be two Ubuntu VMs with Bird iBGP/eBGP + VRRP, on different hosts, outside the HA cluster and additionally with a passthrough network card for each VM, then in fact it should be no different from two physical routers, also in terms of performance, and in fact gives greater m

Re: One bird VM (HA cluster) or two bird VMs (iBGP).

2025-02-26 Thread Bernd Naumann
Yes, two VMs is the way. But "nothing is wrong" with a "HA" foobar feature of a Cluster. Sure it depends what the Cluster will actually do and how it will behave, and maybe /I/ would not trust VMware, but with ganeti we wanted to bring up certain VMs up on a different node as soon as possible. Also

Re: One bird VM (HA cluster) or two bird VMs (iBGP).

2025-02-26 Thread Volodymyr Pidgornyi
That was the second remark :) However, RSes can be run in VMs, the only question is about RIB size and updates rate. 26.02.2025 19:53, Alarig Le Lay via Bird-users: I completely agree. I wouldn’t try to rely on something as shady as virtualisation “HA” when something as simple as iBGP and VRR

Re: One bird VM (HA cluster) or two bird VMs (iBGP).

2025-02-26 Thread Alarig Le Lay via Bird-users
I completely agree. I wouldn’t try to rely on something as shady as virtualisation “HA” when something as simple as iBGP and VRRP is available. I would even try to put my routers outside of any VM. On Wed 26 Feb 2025 19:23:27 GMT, Volodymyr Pidgornyi wrote: > Hi. > > You would not install single

Re: One bird VM (HA cluster) or two bird VMs (iBGP).

2025-02-26 Thread Volodymyr Pidgornyi
Hi. You would not install single bird instance on vmware HA cluster since you'll get sessions flaps when instance restart on falures. Right way is to run two different instances on different cluster nodes with HA deactivated for these instances and setup sessions from each bird instance. 26.