Re: Massive increase of SERVFAIL after April 28th 2025.

2025-05-01 Thread Mark Andrews
Also don’t use +short if you want to see the NSID. From my corner of the internet I get the following. % dig +nsid version.bind. txt ch @dns4.p08.nsone.net ; <<>> DiG 9.21.3-dev <<>> +nsid version.bind. txt ch @dns4.p08.nsone.net ;; global options: +cmd ;; Got answer: ;; ->>HEADER<<- opcode: QUE

Re: Massive increase of SERVFAIL after April 28th 2025.

2025-05-01 Thread Carlos Horowicz via bind-users
Hi Vincent using a conventional resolver (no rpz, no forwards, no forward zones) from our Miami cloud: Tracing to ftp.lip6.fr[a] via 190.185.104.10, maximum of 3 retries 190.185.104.10 (190.185.104.10)  |\___ g.ext.nic.fr [fr] (2001:0678:004c:::::0001)  | |\___ soleil.uvsq

Re: Massive increase of SERVFAIL after April 28th 2025.

2025-05-01 Thread Michael Richardson
vinc...@cojot.name wrote: > I've been running bind (since bind 4) in my home/lab for around 3 decades. I > went that route because I wanted: A) to be abstracted from the ISP's DNS > servers and B) to have a local DNS cache. Ditto. > I run 'bind9.16' on RHEL/Linux using the defau

Re: Massive increase of SERVFAIL after April 28th 2025.

2025-05-01 Thread Michael Richardson
Rob McEwen via bind-users wrote: > I strongly suspect that this was caused (even if indirectly?) by the MASSIVE > and many-hours-long power outages in Europe, mainly in Spain and > Portugal. That started on April 28, 2025, at approximately 6:33 a.m. Eastern > Time (ET) - and the

Massive increase of SERVFAIL after April 28th 2025.

2025-05-01 Thread vincent
Hi everyone, I've been running bind (since bind 4) in my home/lab for around 3 decades. I went that route because I wanted: A) to be abstracted from the ISP's DNS servers and B) to have a local DNS cache. Fast forward to today and I have several servers, each with a copy of my zones and the

Re: Massive increase of SERVFAIL after April 28th 2025.

2025-05-01 Thread Rob McEwen via bind-users
From vinc...@cojot.name until a few days ago (April 28th?) when the amount of SERVFAIL started going ballistic and started preventing the resolution of a lot of DNS names on the internet to the point where DNS was unusable I strongly suspect that this was caused (even if indirectly?) by the M

Re: Massive increase of SERVFAIL after April 28th 2025.

2025-05-01 Thread vincent
Hi Rob, Unfortunately, as soon as I remove the 'forwarders' in any of my named servers, the problem comes back. The output in my previous message was captured just a few minutes ago after I had disabled 'forwaders' in one of my bind servers. Regards, Vincent On Thu, 1 May 2025, Rob McEw

Re: Massive increase of SERVFAIL after April 28th 2025.

2025-05-01 Thread Rob McEwen via bind-users
In that case, someone smarter and more knowledgeable on this list will hopefully help you. But first - one last suggestion - if you find that forwards to 3rd party servers work - but turning those off causes issues - you should probably make sure that your "root hints" are updated, and purge an

Re: Massive increase of SERVFAIL after April 28th 2025.

2025-05-01 Thread Ondřej Surý
> dig +short +nsid version.bind. txt ch @dns4.p08.nsone.net This needs to be this: ^^^ You missed @ and thus you asked your local resolver. Ondrej -- Ondřej Surý — ISC (He/Him) My working hours and your working hours may be different. Please do not feel obligated to reply outside your normal w

Re: Massive increase of SERVFAIL after April 28th 2025.

2025-05-01 Thread vincent
Hi Michael, Thank you so much for chiming in! My guess is that something is in the way, and it's probably trying to attack you (or your ISP) with fake replies, but it's doing a bad job. When I do: dig +short +nsid version.bind. txt ch dns4.p08.nsone.net I get: "9.21.2-1+0~20241120.131+

Re: Massive increase of SERVFAIL after April 28th 2025.

2025-05-01 Thread vincent
Hi Carlos, First of all, I'd like to say how sorry I was for those affected, as I was watching the events unfold down south. I've rebuilt dnstracer for RHEL9 and I don't really understand what's going on here.. Here's the output for ftp.lip6.fr: # dnstracer -q cname -s M.GTLD-SERVERS.NET

Re: Massive increase of SERVFAIL after April 28th 2025.

2025-05-01 Thread Jeremy C. Reed
> /var/log/named/auth_servers.log:01-May-2025 11:05:26.694 lame-servers: info: > SERVFAIL unexpected RCODE resolving 'isis.lip6.fr//IN': 193.51.24.1#53 do some queries for these many examples, like dig @193.51.24.1 isis.lip6.fr dig @132.227.60.2 osiris.lip6.fr dig +norec @198.51.4

Re: Massive increase of SERVFAIL after April 28th 2025.

2025-05-01 Thread Carlos Horowicz via bind-users
Hi, For SERVFAIL to happen, ALL authoritative for the affected domains must have been in Datacenters in Spain, Portugal or southern France. I live in Spain, and as 12:33 CET I lost not only power but basic telephony, cellular telephony and cellular data. Everything. Power generators were onl

Re: Massive increase of SERVFAIL after April 28th 2025.

2025-05-01 Thread vincent
Hi Rob, Thank you for your message. Yes, I've already done all that. (got the latest root zone, restart named each time I switch from forwarders to non-forwarders, etc...). I am using lip6.fr as an example because it hosts some mirrors for Fedora Linux but I am pretty sure it's not the only si

Re: Massive increase of SERVFAIL after April 28th 2025.

2025-05-01 Thread vincent
Hi again Carlos, I really don't understand how it works for you and not for me on a RHEL host in Canada. Here's what I was trying with 8.8.8.8 and 1.1.1.1: # dnstracer -o -e -s 8.8.8.8 ftp.lip6.fr Tracing to ftp.lip6.fr[a] via 8.8.8.8, maximum of 3 retries 8.8.8.8 (8.8.8.8) # dnstracer -o -

Re: Massive increase of SERVFAIL after April 28th 2025.

2025-05-01 Thread vincent
On Thu, 1 May 2025, Michael Richardson wrote: Rob McEwen via bind-users wrote: > I strongly suspect that this was caused (even if indirectly?) by the MASSIVE > and many-hours-long power outages in Europe, mainly in Spain and > Portugal. That started on April 28, 2025, at approximat

Re: Massive increase of SERVFAIL after April 28th 2025.

2025-05-01 Thread vincent
Thank you, Ondřej! I'm getting the same answer from all my hosts: # dig +short +nsid version.bind. txt ch @dns4.p08.nsone.net "366568643ba5103a1f441fbc3c502ed2eaa0b3d9" Vincent On Thu, 1 May 2025, Ondřej Surý wrote: dig +short +nsid version.bind. txt ch @dns4.p08.nsone.net This needs to

Re: Massive increase of SERVFAIL after April 28th 2025.

2025-05-01 Thread Michael Richardson
Ondřej Surý wrote: >> dig +short +nsid version.bind. txt ch @dns4.p08.nsone.net > This needs to be this: ^^^ p> You missed @ and thus you asked your local resolver. Yes, you are right. Bad on me I actually have a script that does this, but I transcribed it for posting. I get: obiwan-

Re: Massive increase of SERVFAIL after April 28th 2025.

2025-05-01 Thread Mark Andrews
I don’t think there was anything wrong with your servers. The log messages indicate problems with the authoritative servers. In theory authoritative DNS servers should be able to serve content until the zone content expires. They should be able to be powered off then rebooted and continue to se