Re: Name-server redundancy

2014-06-10 Thread Blake Hudson
If you want to ensure well working failover you must, at some point, test it. Even better, you may want to regularly test it (check out Netflix's Chaos Monkey). One way to run a simulation would be to use a firewall rule or static route to block access between your test client/recursive server

Re: Name-server redundancy

2014-06-10 Thread Kevin Darcy
You're right: I misinterpreted "no name-server" as "no such host" (aka NXDOMAIN), but actually your explanation makes more sense. - Kevin On 6/9/2014 6:07 PM, Barry Margolin wrote: In article , Kevin Darcy wrote: That scenario sti

Re: Name-server redundancy

2014-06-09 Thread Barry Margolin
In article , Kevin Darcy wrote: > That scenario still shouldn't have led to an NXDOMAIN. If none of the > delegated nameservers are responding, you'd get a timeout or SERVFAIL. > So I think there's still some investigation to be done. But using dig > instead of nslookup at least makes things

Re: Name-server redundancy

2014-06-09 Thread Sid Shapiro
Again - thanks for the quick response - that'll teach me to post without all the facts. I simply don't remember what the specific error was, darn it. It might have been NXDOMAIN or SERVFAIL - I didn't write it down. The test I was running was on a barely, if ever used, domain, so I was pretty sure

Re: Name-server redundancy

2014-06-09 Thread Kevin Darcy
That scenario still shouldn't have led to an NXDOMAIN. If none of the delegated nameservers are responding, you'd get a timeout or SERVFAIL. So I think there's still some investigation to be done. But using dig instead of nslookup at least makes things clearer :-) Of course, caching may compli

Re: Name-server redundancy

2014-06-09 Thread Sid Shapiro
Thanks, Kevin, for your quick reply. In the last few minutes, I've come to realize that my problem is likely that the domain is only registered with two name servers - the one which were offline. Even though the zone has 6 NS records, the .com servers probably only know of the ones in the registrat

Re: Name-server redundancy

2014-06-09 Thread Kevin Darcy
Well, you shouldn't be getting an NXDOMAIN just because some of your auth servers are off-line, but you could get some query timeouts if performance to your failover servers is really bad (or blocked, due to firewall rules, bad routes, etc.), or, if your expire times are *really* low, and the m