Re: SERVFAIL error during the evening

2024-06-24 Thread Michael Batchelder
>> Hello Michael >> Thank you for your response. Here is a pcap file and some logs. > > Hello Sami, > > Your pcap shows your resolver making thousands of queries that get > no responses (or at least the pcap does not contain them). There's > not much I can say, beyond that this does not appear to

Re: qname minimization: me too :(

2024-06-24 Thread Mark Andrews
I should add that a resolver should be able to stop on the first NXDOMAIN. It’s only because we know there are mis-implementations of the protocol (returning NXDOMAIN rather that NOERROR for empty non-terminals) and mis-configurations (missing delegating NS records) that the default is to cont

Re: qname minimization: me too :(

2024-06-24 Thread Mark Andrews
It’s just a false positive when the result is NXDOMAIN. Because people forget to put delegating NS records in parent zones when both are served by the same server the lookups continue on NXDOMAIN. There is an issue to address this. -- Mark Andrews > On 25 Jun 2024, at 06:36, Peter wrote: >

Re: qname minimization: me too :(

2024-06-24 Thread Peter
On Fri, Jun 21, 2024 at 04:58:55PM +0200, Stephane Bortzmeyer wrote: ! On Fri, Jun 21, 2024 at 07:03:14AM +, ! 65;6800;1c Michael Batchelder wrote ! a message of 59 lines which said: ! ! > You'll need to fix these zones so that the response is NOERROR rather than NXDOMAIN. ! ! Yes and, if

Re: SERVFAIL error during the evening

2024-06-24 Thread Michael Batchelder
> Hello Michael > Thank you for your response. Here is a pcap file and some logs. Hello Sami, Your pcap shows your resolver making thousands of queries that get no responses (or at least the pcap does not contain them). There's not much I can say, beyond that this does not appear to be a proble