Are you using "accurate" backups?
It might be useful to see what these queries print:
select jobid,count(*) from file where jobid in
(181371,181679,182032,182350,182668,182718,183093,183408,183724,184039,184354,184669,184984,185615)
and fileindex = 0 group by jobid;
select jobid,count(*) from
I think the fatal error is that it can't find records in the File table for
any of the JobIds that it is consolidating.
Have the file records for those jobs been pruned? You could check with an SQL
query like this:
select jobid,count(*) from file where jobid in
(181371,181679,182032,182350,1826