Re: DIS: proto: truthfulness in registration

2007-08-23 Thread Zefram
Peekee wrote: >What does this actually do? A non-player entity violates the rules. So what? Ultimately e can be exiled. But the intent is more that people who actually want to play Agora, such as you, will avoid breaking the rules. -zefram

Re: DIS: proto: truthfulness in registration

2007-08-23 Thread Peekee
Quoting Zefram <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: Any entity that CANNOT register MUST NOT make such an announcement. What does this actually do? A non-player entity violates the rules. So what? -- Peekee

DIS: proto: truthfulness in registration

2007-08-22 Thread Zefram
proto-proposal: truthfulness in registration AI: 1 {{{ Amend rule 869 by appending to the paragraph that describes how to register the sentence Any entity that CANNOT register MUST NOT make such an announcement. [This adds a R2149-like requirement for truthfulness in purported regis

DIS: proto: truthfulness

2007-05-23 Thread Zefram
Proto-proposal: truthfulness {{{ Enact a rule with title "Truthfulness" and text: Players are prohibited from deliberately or recklessly making false statements in any public message. Merely quoting a false statement does not constitute making it for the purposes of this

Re: DIS: proto: truthfulness

2007-05-22 Thread Michael Slone
On 5/20/07, Ed Murphy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Do you disagree that the phrase should be added, or that it would succeed in de-criminalizing claims such as BobTHJ's? (Assuming for the sake of argument that at least one of em was, in fact, false.) I disagree that the phrase would decriminaliz

Re: DIS: proto: truthfulness

2007-05-20 Thread Ed Murphy
Maud wrote: On 5/19/07, Ed Murphy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: And "as if they were true". This would de-criminalize things like BobTHJ's recent claims to act on behalf of PP and HP2, which (in context) were clearly only presented as if they /might/ be true. I disagree. The action of attempti

Re: DIS: proto: truthfulness

2007-05-20 Thread Michael Slone
On 5/19/07, Ed Murphy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: And "as if they were true". This would de-criminalize things like BobTHJ's recent claims to act on behalf of PP and HP2, which (in context) were clearly only presented as if they /might/ be true. I disagree. The action of attempting to act on b

Re: DIS: proto: truthfulness

2007-05-19 Thread Ed Murphy
Maud wrote: On 5/19/07, Zefram <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Players are prohibited from making false statements in any public message. You probably need the word ``willful'' in there somewhere. And "as if they were true". This would de-criminalize things like BobTHJ's recent clai

Re: DIS: proto: truthfulness

2007-05-19 Thread quazie
Michael Slone wrote: On 5/19/07, Zefram <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Players are prohibited from making false statements in any public message. You probably need the word ``willful'' in there somewhere. yes, please add willful

Re: DIS: proto: truthfulness

2007-05-19 Thread Michael Slone
On 5/19/07, Zefram <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Players are prohibited from making false statements in any public message. You probably need the word ``willful'' in there somewhere. -- C. Maud Image (Michael Slone) If Claustronomic doesn't exist, why did I get mail from it just the o

Re: DIS: proto: truthfulness

2007-05-19 Thread Zefram
comex wrote: >This could make it much harder to dismiss a CFJ for being not relevant to the >rules. Yes, I hadn't thought of that. It means that a CFJ on any statement that has been made publicly can't be dismissed on those grounds. In the really irrelevant cases it could still usually be dismi

Re: DIS: proto: truthfulness

2007-05-19 Thread comex
On Saturday 19 May 2007 11:42 am, Zefram wrote: > Players are prohibited from making false statements in any public > message. This could make it much harder to dismiss a CFJ for being not relevant to the rules. pgpn281lRWgpt.pgp Description: PGP signature

DIS: proto: truthfulness

2007-05-19 Thread Zefram
proto-proposal: truthfulness {{{ Enact a rule with title "Truthfulness" and text: Players are prohibited from making false statements in any public message. }}} -zefram