Re: DIS: Re: BUS: CFJ: Rule 2226

Pavitra wrote: > Aaron Goldfein wrote: >> I CFJ on the following sentence. When a judge with judicial rank 0 has >> eir judgement overruled on appeal, then it is decreased by 1 and e >> CANNOT increase it for 30 days afterward. Incidentally, this CFJ is trivially FALSE because R2226 says "if the

Re: DIS: Re: BUS: CFJ: Rule 2226

Pavitra wrote: > Aaron Goldfein wrote: >> I CFJ on the following sentence. When a judge with judicial rank 0 has >> eir judgement overruled on appeal, then it is decreased by 1 and e >> CANNOT increase it for 30 days afterward. >> >> Evidence: >> >> Rule 2226 >> >> When a judgement is overru

Re: DIS: Re: BUS: CFJ: Rule 2226

On Mon, Aug 10, 2009 at 11:57 AM, Pavitra wrote: > I also think "unless" constitutes a claim of precedence. Do we have > rules or precedents about what happens when two contradictory clauses in > the same Rule each claim precedence over the other? Yes! -- -c.

DIS: Re: BUS: CFJ: Rule 2226

Aaron Goldfein wrote: > I CFJ on the following sentence. When a judge with judicial rank 0 has > eir judgement overruled on appeal, then it is decreased by 1 and e > CANNOT increase it for 30 days afterward. > > Evidence: > > Rule 2226 > > When a judgement is overruled on appeal, if the pr