Re: DIS: Proto-Proposal: Clarify REMAND vs REASSIGN

2008-07-26 Thread Zefram
Taral wrote: >Proto-Proposal: Clarify REMAND vs REASSIGN That's not a clarification, it's a shift in the balance between these two options. I like the balance where it is, and don't have your objection to gratuitous REASSIGNments. >{Note that these say judgement, not arguments. As worded, neithe

DIS: Proto-Proposal: Clarify REMAND vs REASSIGN

2008-07-25 Thread Taral
Proto-Proposal: Clarify REMAND vs REASSIGN AI1.7 Amend rule 911 by replacing the text: * REMAND, appropriate if there is serious doubt about the appropriateness of the prior judgement but the judge believes that the judge of the prior case can make a better judgement