Ed Murphy wrote:
>What about the case where a judge whose verdict of GUILTY is
>overturned after e delivers sentence?
Interesting one. Perhaps e should ultimately lose a VC for the sentence
having become inapplicable, but still I think a blue one.
-zefram
Zefram wrote:
Ed Murphy wrote:
the prior judge loses one Blue VC, unless the prior
question is on sentencing.
It's deliberate that a judge whose sentence is overturned loses a
different colour of VC from the one that e gained. It makes black VCs
more interesting.
What a
Ed Murphy wrote:
> the prior judge loses one Blue VC, unless the prior
> question is on sentencing.
It's deliberate that a judge whose sentence is overturned loses a
different colour of VC from the one that e gained. It makes black VCs
more interesting.
-zefram
Eris wrote:
On 12/4/07, Ed Murphy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
Eris wrote:
I think this was deliberate.
If a judge judges GUILTY and delivers sentence, e gains 1 Blue and
1 Black. If the GUILTY is overturned, e only loses 1 Blue. That's
wrong, whether it was deliberate or not.
I see. Why n
On 12/4/07, Ed Murphy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> Eris wrote:
>
> > I think this was deliberate.
>
> If a judge judges GUILTY and delivers sentence, e gains 1 Blue and
> 1 Black. If the GUILTY is overturned, e only loses 1 Blue. That's
> wrong, whether it was deliberate or not.
I see. Why not j
Eris wrote:
I think this was deliberate.
If a judge judges GUILTY and delivers sentence, e gains 1 Blue and
1 Black. If the GUILTY is overturned, e only loses 1 Blue. That's
wrong, whether it was deliberate or not.
I think this was deliberate.
On 12/4/07, Ed Murphy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> Proto-Proposal: Fix revocation of judicial salary
> (AI = 2, please)
>
> Amend Rule 2126 (Voting Power) by replacing this text:
>
>(-B) A player who is recused from a judicial case with cause
> los
Proto-Proposal: Fix revocation of judicial salary
(AI = 2, please)
Amend Rule 2126 (Voting Power) by replacing this text:
(-B) A player who is recused from a judicial case with cause
loses one Blue VC. A player who is the prior judge in an
appeal case where a judgem
8 matches
Mail list logo
