omd wrote:
> On Mon, Apr 25, 2011 at 5:26 PM, Ed Murphy wrote:
>> omd wrote:
>>
>>> NoV: I violated Rule 2158 by failing to assign a judgement to CFJ 2664 ASAP.
>>> I close this NoV.
>>> I initiate a criminal case regarding this NoV.
>>> Arguments: I am NOT GUILTY because the breach occurred more
On Mon, 25 Apr 2011, ais523 wrote:
> On Mon, 2011-04-25 at 17:56 -0400, Sean Hunt wrote:
> > On 11-04-25 05:53 PM, omd wrote:
> > As a Mao player, I'm a big fan of punishing every minor breach, by the
> > way. If there was a general consensus that this is desirable, I'd be all
> > for it.
>
>
On Mon, 25 Apr 2011, omd wrote:
> But we don't actually do that. I don't have statistics, but as I
> recall, in practice almost all NoVs are for major offenses, and a
> majority go to trial; most minor offenses (of the sort that would clog
> up the courts) are not prosecuted in the first place.
On Mon, 2011-04-25 at 17:56 -0400, Sean Hunt wrote:
> On 11-04-25 05:53 PM, omd wrote:
> > But we don't actually do that. I don't have statistics, but as I
> > recall, in practice almost all NoVs are for major offenses, and a
> > majority go to trial; most minor offenses (of the sort that would cl
On 11-04-25 05:53 PM, omd wrote:
But we don't actually do that. I don't have statistics, but as I
recall, in practice almost all NoVs are for major offenses, and a
majority go to trial; most minor offenses (of the sort that would clog
up the courts) are not prosecuted in the first place. Probab
On Mon, Apr 25, 2011 at 5:35 PM, Kerim Aydin wrote:
> So, every single exchange:
> "NoV: You did/didn't do X."
> followed by either:
> "I contest this, you missed message Y."
> "Sorry, my bad."
> or
> "ok I admit it, no contest."
But we don't actually do that. I don't have statistics, but as I
r
On Mon, 25 Apr 2011, omd wrote:
> Proposal: NoVs suck (AI=2)
>
> Repeal Rule 2230 (Notices of Violation).
So, every single exchange:
"NoV: You did/didn't do X."
followed by either:
"I contest this, you missed message Y."
"Sorry, my bad."
or
"ok I admit it, no contest."
would have to go to cri
On 25 April 2011 21:32, Aaron Goldfein wrote:
> The punishments for NoVs are ridiculously small. Points=class of crime?
> That's absurd. Some of the worst crimes in Agora will only lose you 6
> points, which is practically what you gain for judging one CFJ. I'm all for
> punishing players by takin
The punishments for NoVs are ridiculously small. Points=class of crime?
That's absurd. Some of the worst crimes in Agora will only lose you 6
points, which is practically what you gain for judging one CFJ. I'm all for
punishing players by taking away their points, but I think the punishments
should
9 matches
Mail list logo
