[Acme] Re: Proposal for Enhancing ACME Protocol with ACME++

2025-01-08 Thread Richard Barnes
Hi Tianyu Zhang, Thanks for this proposal. It would be helpful if we could back up a step: What types of attacks are you trying to mitigate here? The mechanism you describe here is very generic; anything at all could go in the newClientAuthz challenges. What sorts of properties of the client mi

[Acme] Re: Proposal for Enhancing ACME Protocol with ACME++

2025-01-08 Thread Michael Richardson
wrote: > If both conditions are met, the CA proceeds with certificate issuance > according to the standard ACME protocol. If the IP addresses do not > match, the CA terminates the connection, as this may indicate a > compromised ACME account. So if the client is behind NAT44 or N