Intent to orphan packages with unreachable maintainer address

2021-01-12 Thread Baptiste Beauplat
Hi,

Following Holger's no-change source-only uploads to have all binaries
built on buildd [1], a couple of RC bugs have been opened because
Maintainers email's are unreachable.

While discussing on #debian-qa how to handle those bugs on packages
without reachable maintainer, Mattia suggested to simply orphan those,
without the need of going through the MIA process. Just to be sure of
what I'm doing, I'm writing this mail as an heads-up.

After carefully reviewing all bugs, I've extracted all packages that, I
believe, qualify for being Orphaned, based on:

- Maintainer email unreachable
- No substitute address found
- Last maintainer upload is over 900 days
- Not part of a Team
- No active Uploaders

I've compile all that data into the attached file packages-data.csv.

The final list of source package that would be orphaned is available in
the attached file dd-list.txt

The MIA Team might want to have look at maintainers that have other
packages (Other packages column in the CSV).

Let me know if I shouldn't process with orphaning those packages,
otherwise, I'll do so in a week.

[1]: https://lists.debian.org/debian-devel/2020/12/msg00419.html
-- 
Baptiste Beauplat - lyknode
Al Nikolov 
   goban
   libdbix-class-htmlwidget-perl

Alberto Furia 
   archmbox

Andy Shevchenko 
   renrot

Angel Ramos 
   cvsdelta

Antonio Ospite 
   kboot-utils

C. Chad Wallace 
   liblingua-en-namecase-perl

Carlos Alberto Silombria Ibarra 
   maildirsync

Chris Grzegorczyk 
   geronimo-ejb-3.0-spec
   geronimo-j2ee-connector-1.5-spec
   geronimo-jms-1.1-spec

Daniel Jared Dominguez 
   wsl

Dmitry Borisyuk 
   fbxkb

Graziano Obertelli 
   geronimo-ejb-3.0-spec (U)
   geronimo-j2ee-connector-1.5-spec (U)
   geronimo-jms-1.1-spec (U)

gustavo panizzo 
   numad (U)

Hamish Moffatt 
   extra-xdg-menus (U)

Jeremías Casteglione 
   numad

Juliane Holzt 
   gwhois

Julián Moreno Patiño 
   john (U)

Kamal Mostafa 
   numad (U)

Kyo Lee 
   geronimo-ejb-3.0-spec (U)
   geronimo-j2ee-connector-1.5-spec (U)
   geronimo-jms-1.1-spec (U)

Leo Iannacone 
   apt-venv

Peter Clifton 
   extra-xdg-menus
   extra-xdg-menus (U)

Petr Baranov 
   libloki

Robert James Clay 
   crashmail

Ruben Molina 
   john

Valerie R Young 
   blag-fortune

Vedran Furač 
   aspell-hr

Source;Maintainer;Uploaders;RC Bug;Reason;Popcorn;Total bugs;RC bugs;Time since last maintainer upload;Time since last maintainer upload (days);Other packages;Comment
apt-venv;Leo Iannacone ;;979347;Unknown user;31;3;1;2014-08-23;2334;60;MIA since 2016
archmbox;Alberto Furia ;;979435;Unknown user;21;3;1;2009-11-23;4068;1;
aspell-hr;Vedran Furač ;;979051;Unknown user;435;3;1;2006-10-10;5208;0;
blag-fortune;Valerie R Young ;;979530;Mailbox full;176;3;1;2017-08-07;1254;0;
crashmail;Robert James Clay ;;976832;Relay error;7;3;1;2018-07-19;908;31;Last upload on feb 2019
cvsdelta;Angel Ramos ;;979428;No MX;28;2;1;2009-05-08;4267;3;MIA since 2009
extra-xdg-menus;Peter Clifton ;Peter Clifton , Hamish Moffatt ;979055;Unknown user;4965;8;1;2008-02-09;4721;1;Inactive DD as uploader (last upload 2010)
fbxkb;Dmitry Borisyuk ;;978624;Unknown user;195;5;1;2014-11-05;2260;0;
geronimo-ejb-3.0-spec;Chris Grzegorczyk ;Graziano Obertelli , Kyo Lee ;979222;NXFAILED;144;2;1;2010-01-03;4027;10;Also affects Kyo Lee , Both MIA since 2010
geronimo-j2ee-connector-1.5-spec;Chris Grzegorczyk ;Graziano Obertelli , Kyo Lee ;979058;NXFAILED;597;2;1;2010-01-29;4001;10;
geronimo-jms-1.1-spec;Chris Grzegorczyk ;Graziano Obertelli , Kyo Lee ;979056;NXFAILED;1289;4;1;2010-01-03;4027;10;
goban;Al Nikolov ;;979875;Timeout;29;1;1;2017-06-08;1314;7;Last upload jan 2019
gwhois;Juliane Holzt ;;979221;Unknown user;162;13;1;2015-04-17;2097;1;
john;Ruben Molina ;Julián Moreno Patiño ;979054;Unknown user;2527;24;1;2013-09-05;2686;5;
kboot-utils;Antonio Ospite ;;979641;Unknown user;2;1;1;2013-12-14;2586;0;
libdbix-class-htmlwidget-perl;Al Nikolov ;;979529;Timeout;9;1;1;2017-06-08;1314;7;
liblingua-en-namecase-perl;C. Chad Wallace ;;979502;Unknown user;17;2;1;2008-03-11;4690;0;
libloki;Petr Baranov ;;979357;Unknown user;32;4;1;2011-07-03;3481;0;
maildirsync;Carlos Alberto Silombria Ibarra ;;979345;Unknown user;39;3;1;2015-03-03;2142;0;
numad;Jeremías Casteglione ;gustavo panizzo , Kamal Mostafa ;976328;Unknown user;154;2;1;2016-12-26;1478;0;
renrot;Andy Shevchenko ;;979218;Relay error;116;4;1;2009-01-04;4391;0;
wsl;Daniel Jared Dominguez ;;979513;Unknown user;16;1;1;2012-11-17;2978;0;


OpenPGP_signature
Description: OpenPGP digital signature


Re: Intent to orphan packages with unreachable maintainer address

2021-01-12 Thread Steve Langasek
On Tue, Jan 12, 2021 at 09:43:20PM +0100, Baptiste Beauplat wrote:
> Hi,
> 
> Following Holger's no-change source-only uploads to have all binaries
> built on buildd [1], a couple of RC bugs have been opened because
> Maintainers email's are unreachable.
> 
> While discussing on #debian-qa how to handle those bugs on packages
> without reachable maintainer, Mattia suggested to simply orphan those,
> without the need of going through the MIA process. Just to be sure of
> what I'm doing, I'm writing this mail as an heads-up.
> 
> After carefully reviewing all bugs, I've extracted all packages that, I
> believe, qualify for being Orphaned, based on:
> 
> - Maintainer email unreachable
> - No substitute address found

Kamal Mostafa is a DD:

  https://nm.debian.org/person/kamal/

So that seems like a substitute address it should've been possible to find?

> - Last maintainer upload is over 900 days
> - Not part of a Team
> - No active Uploaders
> 
> I've compile all that data into the attached file packages-data.csv.
> 
> The final list of source package that would be orphaned is available in
> the attached file dd-list.txt
> 
> The MIA Team might want to have look at maintainers that have other
> packages (Other packages column in the CSV).
> 
> Let me know if I shouldn't process with orphaning those packages,
> otherwise, I'll do so in a week.
> 
> [1]: https://lists.debian.org/debian-devel/2020/12/msg00419.html
> -- 
> Baptiste Beauplat - lyknode

> Al Nikolov 
>goban
>libdbix-class-htmlwidget-perl
> 
> Alberto Furia 
>archmbox
> 
> Andy Shevchenko 
>renrot
> 
> Angel Ramos 
>cvsdelta
> 
> Antonio Ospite 
>kboot-utils
> 
> C. Chad Wallace 
>liblingua-en-namecase-perl
> 
> Carlos Alberto Silombria Ibarra 
>maildirsync
> 
> Chris Grzegorczyk 
>geronimo-ejb-3.0-spec
>geronimo-j2ee-connector-1.5-spec
>geronimo-jms-1.1-spec
> 
> Daniel Jared Dominguez 
>wsl
> 
> Dmitry Borisyuk 
>fbxkb
> 
> Graziano Obertelli 
>geronimo-ejb-3.0-spec (U)
>geronimo-j2ee-connector-1.5-spec (U)
>geronimo-jms-1.1-spec (U)
> 
> gustavo panizzo 
>numad (U)
> 
> Hamish Moffatt 
>extra-xdg-menus (U)
> 
> Jeremías Casteglione 
>numad
> 
> Juliane Holzt 
>gwhois
> 
> Julián Moreno Patiño 
>john (U)
> 
> Kamal Mostafa 
>numad (U)
> 
> Kyo Lee 
>geronimo-ejb-3.0-spec (U)
>geronimo-j2ee-connector-1.5-spec (U)
>geronimo-jms-1.1-spec (U)
> 
> Leo Iannacone 
>apt-venv
> 
> Peter Clifton 
>extra-xdg-menus
>extra-xdg-menus (U)
> 
> Petr Baranov 
>libloki
> 
> Robert James Clay 
>crashmail
> 
> Ruben Molina 
>john
> 
> Valerie R Young 
>blag-fortune
> 
> Vedran Furač 
>aspell-hr
> 

> Source;Maintainer;Uploaders;RC Bug;Reason;Popcorn;Total bugs;RC bugs;Time 
> since last maintainer upload;Time since last maintainer upload (days);Other 
> packages;Comment
> apt-venv;Leo Iannacone ;;979347;Unknown 
> user;31;3;1;2014-08-23;2334;60;MIA since 2016
> archmbox;Alberto Furia ;;979435;Unknown 
> user;21;3;1;2009-11-23;4068;1;
> aspell-hr;Vedran Furač ;;979051;Unknown 
> user;435;3;1;2006-10-10;5208;0;
> blag-fortune;Valerie R Young ;;979530;Mailbox 
> full;176;3;1;2017-08-07;1254;0;
> crashmail;Robert James Clay ;;976832;Relay 
> error;7;3;1;2018-07-19;908;31;Last upload on feb 2019
> cvsdelta;Angel Ramos ;;979428;No 
> MX;28;2;1;2009-05-08;4267;3;MIA since 2009
> extra-xdg-menus;Peter Clifton ;Peter Clifton 
> , Hamish Moffatt ;979055;Unknown 
> user;4965;8;1;2008-02-09;4721;1;Inactive DD as uploader (last upload 2010)
> fbxkb;Dmitry Borisyuk ;;978624;Unknown 
> user;195;5;1;2014-11-05;2260;0;
> geronimo-ejb-3.0-spec;Chris Grzegorczyk ;Graziano 
> Obertelli , Kyo Lee 
> ;979222;NXFAILED;144;2;1;2010-01-03;4027;10;Also 
> affects Kyo Lee , Both MIA since 2010
> geronimo-j2ee-connector-1.5-spec;Chris Grzegorczyk 
> ;Graziano Obertelli , Kyo Lee 
> ;979058;NXFAILED;597;2;1;2010-01-29;4001;10;
> geronimo-jms-1.1-spec;Chris Grzegorczyk ;Graziano 
> Obertelli , Kyo Lee 
> ;979056;NXFAILED;1289;4;1;2010-01-03;4027;10;
> goban;Al Nikolov 
> ;;979875;Timeout;29;1;1;2017-06-08;1314;7;Last upload jan 
> 2019
> gwhois;Juliane Holzt ;;979221;Unknown 
> user;162;13;1;2015-04-17;2097;1;
> john;Ruben Molina ;Julián Moreno Patiño 
> ;979054;Unknown user;2527;24;1;2013-09-05;2686;5;
> kboot-utils;Antonio Ospite ;;979641;Unknown 
> user;2;1;1;2013-12-14;2586;0;
> libdbix-class-htmlwidget-perl;Al Nikolov 
> ;;979529;Timeout;9;1;1;2017-06-08;1314;7;
> liblingua-en-namecase-perl;C. Chad Wallace 
> ;;979502;Unknown user;17;2;1;2008-03-11;4690;0;
> libloki;Petr Baranov ;;979357;Unknown 
> user;32;4;1;2011-07-03;3481;0;
> maildirsync;Carlos Alberto Silombria Ibarra 
> ;;979345;Unknown user;39;3;1;2015-03-03;2142;0;
> numad;Jeremías Casteglione ;gustavo panizzo 
> , Kamal Mostafa ;976328;Unknown 
> user;154;2;1;2016-12-26;1478;0;
> renrot;Andy Shevchenko ;;979218;Relay 
> error;116;4;1;2009-01-04;4391;0;
> wsl;Daniel Jared Dominguez ;;979513;Unknown