Re: "pytest" command is missing
On 11/4/20 9:27 PM, Novy, Ondrej wrote: > Hi, > > Antonio Terceiro píše v St 04. 11. 2020 v 14:01 -0300: >> Could you ellaborate? Maybe we should have a discussion in the Python >> team so that we implement consistent practices. For example, `gunicorn` >> and `pip` now point to their python3 versions, but you are saying that >> pytest will not do that, what maybe creates more confusion given Debian >> bullseye will not support any other Python. > > "pytest" in buster now points to python2 version of pytest and > "pytest-3" points to python3 version. To prevent confusion after upgrade > I want to keep one stable release with pytest cmd "unoccupied" and keep > pytest-3. > > Bullseye will support Python2 interpreter so user can keep python-pytest > package installed from buster. Moreover, simply invoking "pytest-3" is not enough, one should be using: for pyvers in $$(py3versions -vr 2>/dev/null) ; do \ python$$pyvers -m pytest ; \ done otherwise, only the default version of Python3 is tested, and we really want to test with all available versions (so we get results whenever we're transitioning to a new Python 3 version). Cheers, Thomas Goirand (zigo)
Re: "pytest" command is missing
On Thu, Nov 05, 2020 at 09:28:56AM +0100, Thomas Goirand wrote: > On 11/4/20 9:27 PM, Novy, Ondrej wrote: > > Hi, > > > > Antonio Terceiro píše v St 04. 11. 2020 v 14:01 -0300: > >> Could you ellaborate? Maybe we should have a discussion in the Python > >> team so that we implement consistent practices. For example, `gunicorn` > >> and `pip` now point to their python3 versions, but you are saying that > >> pytest will not do that, what maybe creates more confusion given Debian > >> bullseye will not support any other Python. > > > > "pytest" in buster now points to python2 version of pytest and > > "pytest-3" points to python3 version. To prevent confusion after upgrade > > I want to keep one stable release with pytest cmd "unoccupied" and keep > > pytest-3. > > > > Bullseye will support Python2 interpreter so user can keep python-pytest > > package installed from buster. The python2 interpreter will be supported, but nothing else will, so I don't see the point of this compatibility. I don't think that "keep you old packages from the previous release" is a great upgrade path. Anyway, my point is that we should collective aim to be consistent across the Python packages. The fact that some packages have made their "not *3" binaries be the python3 versions, and others not, due to arbitrary individual maintainer decisions, is a mess. > Moreover, simply invoking "pytest-3" is not enough, one should be using: > > for pyvers in $$(py3versions -vr 2>/dev/null) ; do \ > python$$pyvers -m pytest ; \ > done > > otherwise, only the default version of Python3 is tested, and we really > want to test with all available versions (so we get results whenever > we're transitioning to a new Python 3 version). Sure, but that only applies for package maintainance. People who just want to use pytest to test their Python code have a (IMO pointless) divergence from upstream. This made some sense when there were 2 supported Python ecosystems, but that's now in the past. We could take the opportunity to fix this. signature.asc Description: PGP signature
Re: "pytest" command is missing
On 11/5/20 1:03 PM, terce...@debian.org wrote: > On Thu, Nov 05, 2020 at 09:28:56AM +0100, Thomas Goirand wrote: >> On 11/4/20 9:27 PM, Novy, Ondrej wrote: >>> Hi, >>> >>> Antonio Terceiro píše v St 04. 11. 2020 v 14:01 -0300: Could you ellaborate? Maybe we should have a discussion in the Python team so that we implement consistent practices. For example, `gunicorn` and `pip` now point to their python3 versions, but you are saying that pytest will not do that, what maybe creates more confusion given Debian bullseye will not support any other Python. >>> >>> "pytest" in buster now points to python2 version of pytest and >>> "pytest-3" points to python3 version. To prevent confusion after upgrade >>> I want to keep one stable release with pytest cmd "unoccupied" and keep >>> pytest-3. >>> >>> Bullseye will support Python2 interpreter so user can keep python-pytest >>> package installed from buster. > > The python2 interpreter will be supported, but nothing else will, so I > don't see the point of this compatibility. I don't think that "keep you > old packages from the previous release" is a great upgrade path. well, afaiu, we also will ship python-pip, so that users are able to get their python2 code from other places. > Anyway, my point is that we should collective aim to be consistent > across the Python packages. The fact that some packages have made their > "not *3" binaries be the python3 versions, and others not, due to > arbitrary individual maintainer decisions, is a mess. it's a difficult decision to make. But if people want, then we could ship pytest-is-python2 and pytest-is-python3 packages as well, as long as we don't build-depend on those. Matthias
Re: Merging the PAPT and the DMPT
Ondrej Novy writes: > Hi, > > po 21. 9. 2020 v 13:04 odesílatel Ondrej Novy napsal: > >> Todo: >> >>- send debian-devel-announce (i will) >>- mass-commit vcs+maintainer change >> >> > done. > > Thanks to all who helped me with these. > Yes, thank you! And I'm sure maintainers with lots of packages are even more appreciative than myself :-) Best, Nicholas signature.asc Description: PGP signature
