Harald Schilly wrote:

> There were also concerns about publishing the data. I want to share
> everything, because this is a great opportunity for everyone to read
> what others think about the project. For example, if I have a feeling
> for this or that and I read it from somebody else, it helps that idea.
> It also fosters exchanging different views, between developers and
> users, and so on. I'm not done reading the data, but as far as i can
> see there shouldn't be any concerns.  I see this like a virtual
> gathering of all Sage interested people in a huge room and everyone is
> now able to read each others mind.
> @Simon, about the location / geographical areas: They are very
> unspecific (usa, europe+russia, eastern asia ... there are millions of
> people!), but I can delete that column if it is really a problem. The
> survey wasn't asking about the country and nowhere is this
> information...

I'm sure looking at the survey, you must be able to pick out my entry. I do not 
recall saying anything that I've not at least implied before publicly. I was 
well aware that I could probably be identified when I wrote the comments.

If people can be identified by

* An unusual choice of operating system
* Exact location - I see nothing wrong with unspecific locations myself.
* Detailed research interests

then it would probably not be difficult for others to work out who the comments 
came from. I doubt I could personally determine anyone from their research 
interests, but I'm sure others could.

It might be better for the *next* survey to have two comments areas.

* Confidential - shared with you and William only.

* Public - someone does not care if the comments are made public, even if they 
may be identified from them.



-- 
To post to this group, send an email to sage-devel@googlegroups.com
To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to 
sage-devel-unsubscr...@googlegroups.com
For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/sage-devel
URL: http://www.sagemath.org

Reply via email to