On 8/7/24 09:08, kowa...@denic.de wrote:
This is not my point.
I'm missing an equivalent to the following part of -06, in particular
the 2nd sentence: The "Best Proposed Practices" have not been observed
in operation. The analysis presented in this document suggests that
they could become best practices if deployed.
My proposal would be to add the following sentence before proposals
2&3 in the -07 variant:
"The following practices have not yet been observed in operation
however the analysis presented in this document suggests that they
could become best practices if deployed:"
The authors can determine if they want to insert that sentence, but in
my opinion it is unnecessary and may cause more document churn as the
point of a BCP is that it documents a best practice via the consensus of
the IETF even if not yet deployed. The "if deployed" creates a circular
dependency where it is not a best practice until deployed but there is
no incentive to deploy until it is a best practice. Additionally, the
practices that have and have not been observed are documented in section 5.
-andy
_______________________________________________
regext mailing list -- regext@ietf.org
To unsubscribe send an email to regext-le...@ietf.org
