Hey everyone,
I was working on a procedure to prompt the user for confirmation and found
something a bit strange - it did not appear to read for input when usingt
"racket -i" or in the Emacs Racket REPL buffer. Here is the code:
(define (yn #:read-one-char? [read-one-char? #f])
(display "y/n: ")
(flush-output (current-output-port))
(if read-one-char?
(match (read-char)
[(or #\y #\Y) #t]
[m #f])
(match (read-line)
[(or "y" "Y") #t]
[m #f])))
Regardless if I use read-char or read-line and type y or Y, the behavior seeims
similar, each of the match's second clause is followed because (read-char)
returns #\newline whereas read-line returns "" (empty string).
I mentioned this strange behavior on the Libera chat and got an enlightening
response from tonyg outlining what is happening:
> at the repl, if you type "(read-char)" and press enter, the reader sees ( r e
> a d - c h a r ) NEWLINE. When it gets to the close-parenthesis, it executes
> the expression, which reads the NEWLINE character and returns. Similar for
> read-line, where it sees NEWLINE and returns an empty line
>
> try typing (list (read-line) (read-line))
I can confirm tonyg's solution works. The (list (read-char) (read-char)) also
appears to work, though one always has to type a final newline to send the
line-buffered input.
The behavior feels very surprising and took me a bit of time to figure out,
even then I didn't really understand it so I had to ask for help. Can this
behavior be changed in a future release? Is a reasonable request or could this
break a lot of code? If this could break stuff, is it worth doing changing it
anyway, so the behavior is less surprising? I hope to understand if it's
agreeable to make a PR for this change before investing the time.
Keep on Racketing!
Winston Weinert
winny.tech
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"Racket Users" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email
to racket-users+unsubscr...@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion on the web visit
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/racket-users/20210924190134.mjxttwqtgeunjbus%40ml1.net.
