> i do it in emacs usually if we are talking about being able to > evaluate chunks.
But Emacs is not an IDE. You began by complaining that DrRacket is not more like other traditional IDEs, and making platform-specific complaints. Is there ANY sense in which Emacs is more platform-specific than DrRacket? (I use Emacs all the time, everywhere; I'm typing this in Emacs on Windows 7. But virtually nothing about Emacs's look is "native".) In short, you're expecting that DrRacket's functionality is going to include a traditional IDE AND Emacs? Is that a reasonable demand? And even if it is reasonable, is it a *consistent* one? Emacs lets you perform all sorts of evaluation tricks but without any promise of program integrity. IDEs, in contrast, have the ability to track the connection between program and evaluation, and hence try to provide some kind of coherence about what you're seeing in the output. DrRacket is in the latter category. Here is a useful little puzzle. I strongly urge you to do this before you go forward in this thread. It involves writing only a very small program, and it is an enlightening experience. Let's call this program v.1 (for version 1). Evaluate it. Now change one of the definitions. Let's call the resulting program v.2. But re-evaluate just that changed definition, not the whole program. Now evaluate an expression E that makes sense in both v.1 and v.2 (ie, refers to the same variables, etc). However, E must have the property that the answer it produces now is different from the answer it would have produced if run against v.1 AND different from the answer it would have produced if run against v.2. That is, the answer that you DO get cannot have originated from either version of the program. At that point you will fully understand Bloch's post and why DrRacket does not do what you seem to want it to do and why DrRacket's position is an eminently sensible one. Shriram _________________________________________________ For list-related administrative tasks: http://lists.racket-lang.org/listinfo/users
