On 06/11/2017 02:28, Steve D'Aprano wrote:
On Sat, 4 Nov 2017 03:57 pm, Michael Torrie wrote:
Can you be more specific? What are some of these "many" ways of aborting
a loop? Help a guy out here.
Aside from more exotic methods such as os.abort, os._exit and signal handlers,
the common ways of breaking out of a loop are:
- raise
- return
- break
Am I being pedantic? Of course I am. But we're programmers -- if we don't have
an accurate and complete understanding of code, who will? Given how many
people find it difficult to understand the semanics of for...else, I think we
need to be pedantic about it.
Take this for-loop:
for I in R:
A
else:
B
C
Here are the various ways of exiting the loop, with Y or N indicating
whether that particular block (or 'suite') is executed:
B C
Normal termination: Y Y
Break from A: N Y
Raise/return/etc from A: N N
Here, we're only interested in whether B and C have different entries,
as that would be the only reason to have an 'else' part in the first place.
And that only happens when the loop is terminated with a Break. Unless
someone knows of any other circumstances where B is not executed but C
is. (Both B and C also contain raise, return, exit(), infinite loops
etc, but that shouldn't effect this point.)
Break inside the loop can also be conditional (I think it has to be if
you want more than one iteration!), which means that sometimes, it will
never break, then you get the Y/Y (or N/N) result. But the expectation
is that there the break COULD be executed, so you will need the 'else'.
--
bartc
--
https://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list
