Peter Otten wrote: > > You are on the right track with staticmethod, but you have to apply it to > fn: > > ... fn = staticmethod(foo)
Thanks Peter, that's a big help. I can solve my problem now, but I'm chasing this further in the name of education, because it seems there is some deep magic happening here that I don't understand. It seems that applying staticfunction() (or perhaps assigning to the class object) is treated differently if it happens in the class defininition, to when it happens at "run time". (My previous attempts to get staticmember() to do the right thing were all "run time" like the examples below.) Say I wanted to keep the need for "staticmember" hidden from subclasses, and do the staticmember() conversion in the base class methods. I've tried 2 ways of doing this (no subclassing here, just to keep it simple): > class B(object): > fn = foo > def try1(self): > print "B.fn is", type(B.fn) > B.fn = staticmethod(B.fn) > print "B try1" > print "B.fn is now", type(B.fn) > B.fn() > > def try2(self): > fn2 = staticmethod(B.fn) > print "B try2" > print "fn2 is now", type(fn2) > fn2() If I try method 1 (assigning to the class object - ignore for a moment the problem of only doing this once!) I get a set of very surprising results: > B.fn is <type 'instancemethod'> > B try1 > B.fn is now <type 'instancemethod'> > Traceback (most recent call last): > File "t_o1.py", line 28, in ? > B().try1() > File "t_o1.py", line 17, in try1 > B.fn() > TypeError: unbound method foo() must be called with B instance as first > argument (got nothing instead) note that assigning the staticmember() result to B.fn does NOT change the type of B.fn!! And foo is treated as a member function. So if I try method 2 (using staticmethod() at runtime): > B try2 > fn2 is now <type 'staticmethod'> > Traceback (most recent call last): > File "t_o1.py", line 27, in ? > B().try2() > File "t_o1.py", line 22, in try2 > fn2() > TypeError: 'staticmethod' object is not callable fn2 is a static method, as I'd expect, but it is somehow not callable? Can someone explain what is going on here? Pointers to language spec, code, PEPs etc gladly accepted. Greg, caught in a twisty little maze of descriptors, all different! -- http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list
