On Mon, 25 Jul 2016 08:13 am, BartC wrote: > A solid end-of-block symbol (as you get with 'else' and 'except' because > then you KNOW that's the end of that block) would have been welcome with > the Python indent scheme.
A solid end-of-block symbol would have been entire redundant and unnecessary. You know when the block ends: it ends when one of two things happen: - you dedent out a level; - you reach the end of file; whichever happens next. Requiring an otherwise pointless end of block delimiter to protect against your cat walking over your keyboard, or clumsy programmers who accidentally hit keys and don't notice, is not a virtue. It doesn't make the language better. It just increases friction when writing code. There are approximately a million billion trillion zillion things that can go wrong if you randomly hit keys without paying attention to what you are doing, and regardless of whether you have a static or dynamic language, only a tiny fraction of them can be detected ahead of time. When you're typing plain English paragraphs like this, why don't you end each sentence with "END", just in case you accidentally delete the punctuation mark and don't notice? END That way, you have less fragile text. END The reader can easily tell when you have the end of a sentence, even if you accidentally delete the full stop, because of the special end marker. END And two end markers could represent the end of a paragraph, just in case you accidentally delete the break between paragraphs? END END Actually, COMMA now that I think about it, COMMA I'm starting to come around to your way of thinking. END We can tag other punctuation marks too, COMMA like commas, COMMA to ensure that our language is less fragile. END No more will you have to fear the ambiguity of accidentally dropping a comma: COLON END END "We invited the strippers, JFK, and Stalin." "We invited the strippers, JFK and Stalin." http://i.imgur.com/fycHx.jpg Instead, COMNA the error becomes obvious: COLON EMD END " QUOTE We invited the strippers, COMMA JFK COMMA and Stalin. END " QUOTE END END -- DASH DASH SPACE END END Steven END END “ QUOTE Cheer up, COMMA ” END they said, COMMA “ QUOTE things could be worse. END ” QUOTE So I cheered up, COMMA and sure enough, COMMA things got worse. END END -- https://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list
