Alexander Vrchoticky <alexander.vrchoti...@gmx.at> added the comment:
I hit that problem too (Python 2.6.5). We have a Windows service application (daemon, in Unix parlance). This is written in Python and uses RotatingFileHandler to rotate files when they exceed 1MB. We look at the files for debugging. For a live view of log entries, we use less.exe in follow mode. If the rotating log handler hits the size limit while the current log file is watched, it throws an exception and logging is broken henceforth. Restarting the service while less.exe is still running does not help, it hits the same exception right from the outset. Since we cannot stop users from looking at the log files, and we cannot have our service application die by user interaction, this is a serious problem. I am confused by the statement that "you should not look at the files as long as they are under the library's control". As I understood, on rotating, the oldest file will be deleted, all others will be renamed, and a new file will be created. No file will remain untouched. As far as the human log reader is concerned, rotation can happen at any time, so all log files are under control of the library for their entire life. If that's true, why bother writing them in the first place? :-) The root problem is that RotatingFileHandler cannot rename the file while less.exe has it open. Under Unix-like file systems, this problem may not appear: Renaming an open file works, and the file descriptor held by less.exe remains valid. The logger is free to create another file with the same name. Under Windows, files and directory entries are more closely related. Hence, the error "The process cannot access the file because it is being used by another process". I do not know if it is possible to work around this. Comments are appreciated. RotatingFileHandler looks like a good match for long-running service applications. If this issue remains unresolved, it is not. A word of warning in the docs seems appropriate in this case. ---------- nosy: +avrchoti _______________________________________ Python tracker <rep...@bugs.python.org> <http://bugs.python.org/issue11270> _______________________________________ _______________________________________________ Python-bugs-list mailing list Unsubscribe: http://mail.python.org/mailman/options/python-bugs-list/archive%40mail-archive.com
