-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA256

Am 11.06.2015 um 14:23 schrieb Viktor Dukhovni:

> There was a problem looking up the addresses of the above hosts, 
> perhaps a nameserver was down, or a network connectivity problem 
> prevented access.
> 
I thought about that too but after my tests it seems to be very
unlikely for me :-)
I just sent a testmail to the user at the orgj.ch domain and instantly
received the same error from postfix.

Jun 11 14:50:35 smtp1 postfix/smtp[29194]: warning: no MX host for
ogrj.ch has a valid address record
Jun 11 14:50:35 smtp1 postfix/smtp[29194]: DA85418006C:
to=<remo...@ogrj.ch>, relay=none, delay=0.08, delays=0.06/0.01/0/0,
dsn=5.4.4, status=bounced (Host or domain name not found. Name service
error for name=smta3.abxsec.com type=A: Host not found)

I checked the dns on the server that issued the error and had no
problems in resolving the MX hosts and get a A record for the MX with
prio 10

# mx records
;; ANSWER SECTION:
ogrj.ch.                3447    IN      MX      120 smtp1.seabix.com.
ogrj.ch.                3447    IN      MX      130 smta4.abxsec.com.
ogrj.ch.                3447    IN      MX      140 smta3.abxsec.com.
ogrj.ch.                3447    IN      MX      510 mtas.abxsec.com.
ogrj.ch.                3447    IN      MX      520 mtaz.abxsec.com.
ogrj.ch.                3447    IN      MX      10 smtasg01.abxsec.com.
ogrj.ch.                3447    IN      MX      20 smtazh01.abxsec.com.
ogrj.ch.                3447    IN      MX      110 smta2.abxsec.com.


# A record for MX with prio 10
;; ANSWER SECTION:
smtasg01.abxsec.com.    768     IN      A       193.246.80.88

# finally test a connection
telnet smtasg01.abxsec.com 25
Trying 193.246.80.88...
Connected to smtasg01.abxsec.com.
Escape character is '^]'.
220 smtasg01.abxsec.com ESMTP Thu, 11 Jun 2015 14:51:01 +0200
QUIT
221 2.0.0 smtasg01.abxsec.com closing connection
Connection closed by foreign host.

So connections to the mx host with prio 10 seems to be working, just
one or two seconds after postfix showed the error.

I really tested a lot of queries manually and NEVER had problems with
resolving. Therefore I wonder why postfix "sees" a problem with EVERY
mail for the domain ogrj.ch

Thanks

tobi

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v2
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=odEb
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

Reply via email to