I can't answer your question, and this may even be off-topic, but copyright
law is never so simple as it may at first seem.

I don't know the law in any country but my own (Britain), but here in
Britain, adding a watermark does NOT make a picture copyright. In Britain,
what makes a picture, or a novel, or a piece of music, or any other
creation, copyright, is the simple fact that you've published it. In other
words, simply putting something on the web _automatically gives you
copyright_.

Unfortunately, the problem then becomes proving it. If two people both claim
to be the creator of the same document, the "winner" - the copyright owner -
is the one who published it first. How do you prove this? You can't. So the
courts get full of people saying "I wrote this", "No, I wrote this", etc..
To safeguard against this, recommended practice is to seal several copies of
your work in a envelopes in which all the edges have been signed and dated
and selotaped over, and then send them by registered post to a number of
trusted parties, including yourself, at creation time (i.e. _before_ you
first publish it). The recipients should be instructed _not to open their
envelope_. In the event of a court dispute, the postmark on the still-sealed
envelopes is considered proof that the work was known to you on or before
that date.

The message "Copyright <name> <date>" is just a warning. It carries no legal
weight. Nor does a watermark. If I create (and publish) a picture, and you
steal it and watermark it, the copyright remains mine.

The law will doubtless be different in other countries. Check on the
internet for the law in yours.

In any case - I seriously doubt that a watermark is unremovable by a
talented hacker.

There's another interesting legal point to consider. If your work is created
by a PROGRAM, do you still own the copyright? (Says I, scarily venturing
into the realms of AI rights here). This is actually a very complicated
issue and one which is likely to remain unresolved for the forseeable
future.

Jill



-----Original Message-----
From: Achilles Maroulis [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Wednesday, April 02, 2003 1:06 PM
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: [PHP-WIN] Help with gd


is if there is way to print a watermark on a picture in order to make it
copyrighted.

-- 
PHP Windows Mailing List (http://www.php.net/)
To unsubscribe, visit: http://www.php.net/unsub.php

Reply via email to